Corporate Risk Mitigation: Strategies for Michigan Employers

Most articles about risk management for employers are about the building, the fleet and the lawsuit.

This one is about the other side of the balance sheet — the risks inside your employee benefits program. For a typical employer with 25 or more employees, benefits is a larger annual line than the entire rest of the insurance program combined. It is also the line most likely to move against you without warning.

There are four risks worth naming. Most employers can describe none of them, and all four are manageable.

CFH Insurance Consultants is an independent employee benefits brokerage in Bloomfield Hills. We are licensed insurance brokers and have been managing benefits programs for Michigan employers since 2007. This article is specifically about benefits risk.

---

Risk 1: cost volatility

The exposure. A renewal arrives with a double-digit increase you did not budget for, and you have four weeks to decide.

Health plan costs do not move like property rates. Property rates track a broad market and a clean loss history keeps them fairly stable. Health renewals move with your funding model, your pool, and — depending on how you are funded — your own claims.

What actually drives it. Small fully insured groups in Michigan are community-rated on age, family composition, geography and tobacco use. Your renewal reflects the pool you sit in, not your group’s behavior. That cuts both ways: a healthy group is subsidizing a sicker one, and a group with genuine claims is being protected.

How to manage it.

• Know your funding model and why you are in it. Fully insured, level-funded and self-funded distribute volatility very differently.
• Go to market every year, not every third year. The spread between best and worst quote for the same group is routinely wide enough to matter.
• Budget a renewal range, not a renewal number.
• Get the renewal early enough to act on it. A renewal delivered in October for a January effective date is not a negotiation; it is an announcement.

---

Risk 2: claims concentration

The exposure. One catastrophic claim — a premature birth, a transplant, a high-cost specialty drug — lands in a small group and reshapes your renewal for years.

This is the risk employers understand least. In a 60-life group, a single ongoing claim can represent a large share of total spend. There is no version of plan design that prevents it. The only question is who absorbs it.

How to manage it.

• Fully insured transfers the risk entirely to the carrier. You pay for that transfer, and for a healthy group you often overpay — but if you cannot absorb a bad year, this is what you are buying.
• Level funding caps your exposure at the stop-loss layer, a number you know in advance. This is usually the right structure for a healthy group between roughly 10 and 150 employees.
• Self-funding requires a deliberate stop-loss strategy: specific stop-loss for individual claims, aggregate stop-loss for total plan spend, and attention to lasering and contract terms at renewal.

The mistake we see most often is a healthy group sitting fully insured for years, paying the risk-transfer premium without ever modeling the alternative — and, less often but more painfully, a group with known high-cost claims being sold level funding on the strength of a good first-year quote.

---

Risk 3: compliance and penalty exposure

The exposure. This one is quiet until it is expensive, because nothing visibly breaks.

• ERISA. Most employer-sponsored health and welfare plans are ERISA plans, requiring a written plan document, a Summary Plan Description distributed to participants, and Form 5500 for plans with 100 or more participants. Late 5500 filings accrue penalties per day.
• ACA employer mandate. At 50 or more full-time-equivalent employees you are an Applicable Large Employer and must offer affordable, minimum-value coverage and report it on Forms 1094-C and 1095-C. The FTE calculation aggregates part-time hours, which is how employers cross the threshold without noticing.
• COBRA. At 20 or more employees, continuation coverage with notices on a strict timetable. Missed notices are common and entirely avoidable.
• Section 125. Pre-tax payroll deductions require an adopted cafeteria plan document. A surprising number of employers deduct pre-tax without ever having adopted one.
• Michigan Earned Sick Time Act. ESTA changed accrual and usage rules for most Michigan employers and interacts with benefits eligibility, particularly for variable-hour staff.

How to manage it. Assign it to a named owner with a calendar — internally, or to your broker. Most compliance failures are not judgment errors; they are nobody’s job.

---

Risk 4: fiduciary exposure

The exposure. The newest of the four, and the least appreciated.

Sponsoring a group health plan carries fiduciary obligations. Recent federal transparency requirements have shifted more responsibility onto plan sponsors to understand what their plan pays and what their vendors are compensated. Litigation in this area has moved from retirement plans toward health plans.

How to manage it.

• Know what your broker and your vendors are paid, and by whom. Ask directly and get it in writing.
• Keep a record of the decisions you made and why — the quotes you gathered, the options you modeled, the reasoning behind the design you chose. A documented, reasoned process is the substance of a prudent one.
• Review vendor arrangements periodically rather than rolling them forward indefinitely.

This is a developing area of law. Treat this section as a prompt to raise it with your benefits counsel, not as legal advice.

---

Where benefits risk touches disability

Exactly one place: disability.

Workers’ compensation covers work-related injury. Short-term disability covers everything else. Michigan has no state disability program, unlike California, New York, New Jersey, Rhode Island and Hawaii — so if you do not sponsor STD, an employee having surgery on a Saturday has no wage replacement beyond banked PTO.

Employers who have not mapped that boundary make one of two mistakes: they leave a gap, or they fund the same lost weeks twice because the disability policy was never written to coordinate with comp. Michigan’s coordination-of-benefits provision permits certain offsets, but it depends on policy language and who paid the premium. Settle it when you place the coverage, not after a claim.

---

Strategic Risk Management and Mitigation for Michigan Employers

Five questions. If you cannot answer three of them, the program is being managed by default rather than by decision.

1. What funding model are we on, and why that one?
2. How many carriers were asked to quote at our last renewal?
3. Who files our 5500, and when was the last one filed?
4. Do we have an adopted Section 125 plan document?
5. What is our broker paid, and by whom?

---

Frequently asked questions

We are fully insured. Do these risks apply? Cost volatility and claims concentration are largely transferred to the carrier — that is what you are paying for. Compliance and fiduciary exposure apply regardless of funding model.

How often should a benefits program be reviewed? Market it annually. Review funding strategy and compliance posture at least every two years, and immediately after any significant change in headcount, since crossing 20, 50 or 100 employees changes your obligations.

---

Have your benefits risk reviewed

We will look at your funding model, your renewal history, your compliance posture and your vendor arrangements, and tell you plainly where the exposure is. If it is well managed, we will say so.

Sunny Connolly
Sr. Partner & Head of Growth and Partnerships
CFH Insurance Consultants
41000 Woodward Avenue, Suite 350 East, Bloomfield Hills, MI 48304

Call 248.370.8853 or book a 30-minute review.

---

General information for Michigan employers, not legal advice. ERISA, ACA and fiduciary obligations are fact-specific and this is an actively developing area — confirm your situation with benefits counsel.