Small Business Insurance: Key Coverages for Protection and Compliance

Most small business owners in Michigan think about insurance in terms of what could go wrong with the building, the vehicles or a lawsuit. That is one half of the picture. The other half — the half that decides whether you can hire the person you want, keep the person you have, and stay on the right side of federal and state law — is the coverage you provide to your employees.

This guide covers the employee benefits side: what each coverage actually does, what it costs a Michigan employer of your size, which pieces are legally required, and how to put a package together without overpaying for it.

CFH Insurance Consultants is an independent employee benefits brokerage in Bloomfield Hills. We are licensed insurance brokers and work only on the benefits side — group health, dental, vision, life, disability and the compliance that surrounds them. We do not write property, auto or liability coverage, and there is a short honest section near the end on how to think about those.

Key takeaways

• Group health insurance is the anchor coverage. Everything else is built around it.
• Under 50 full-time-equivalent employees, you are not required to offer health coverage. At 50 or more, the ACA employer mandate applies.
• Dental, vision, life and disability are inexpensive relative to health and do a disproportionate amount of the retention work.
• Level-funded plans have become the default recommendation for healthy Michigan groups between roughly 10 and 150 employees.
• Compliance failures — 5500s, COBRA notices, ACA reporting — cost more in penalties than the coverage itself.

---

Essential Coverages for Small Business Protection and Risk Management

Employee benefits insurance is the set of coverages an employer sponsors on behalf of its workforce. The employer typically pays a share of the premium, the employee pays the rest through payroll deduction, and the whole arrangement is governed by a mix of federal law (ERISA, the ACA, COBRA, HIPAA) and Michigan-specific rules.

Legally, a business with fewer than 50 full-time-equivalent employees is not required to offer health coverage at all. Practically, in the Michigan labor market, an employer competing for skilled workers without a health plan is competing with one hand tied. Benefits are the second line of every job posting after pay, and for candidates with families they are frequently the first thing compared.

The question for most small employers is not whether to offer benefits. It is how to offer a defensible package at a cost the business can carry through a bad year.

---

Group health insurance: the anchor coverage

Group health is where the majority of the money goes and where the majority of the decisions are made.

What it covers. Preventive care, physician visits, hospitalization, prescription drugs, emergency care, mental health and substance use treatment, and maternity care. Since the ACA, all fully insured small group plans in Michigan must cover the ten essential health benefits with no annual or lifetime dollar limits.

How Michigan employers buy it. Most small employers work through the major Michigan carriers — Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan, Priority Health, HAP, and the national carriers that write in the state. Networks vary meaningfully by region. A plan that looks excellent in Metro Detroit may have a thin network in the Upper Peninsula, and a West Michigan employer often gets better economics from a carrier with deep Grand Rapids hospital contracts.

What drives your rate. For fully insured small groups, Michigan rates are set on age, family composition, geography and tobacco use — not on your claims history. That is worth understanding, because it means a small group with a genuinely healthy population is subsidizing sicker groups in the same rating pool. Which leads directly to the next point.

Fully insured, level-funded, and self-funded

• Fully insured. You pay a fixed premium. The carrier takes all the risk. Simplest, most predictable, and for a healthy group, usually the most expensive.
• Level-funded. You pay a fixed monthly amount that covers expected claims, administration and stop-loss protection. If your group’s claims come in under expectations, a share of the surplus comes back to you at year end. Downside protection is capped by the stop-loss layer.
• Self-funded. You pay claims as they occur, with stop-loss coverage above a threshold. The most control and the most volatility. Generally appropriate above roughly 100–150 employees.

For healthy Michigan groups between about 10 and 150 lives, level funding has become the most common recommendation. It converts a small group out of the community-rated pool and lets a good risk profile show up as money. It is not right for every group — a company with several high-cost ongoing claims is usually better off fully insured — and the honest answer requires looking at your census.

---

Group dental insurance

Dental is inexpensive and disproportionately visible to employees.

Typical structures pay 100% of preventive care (cleanings, exams, x-rays), 70–80% of basic services (fillings, extractions), and 50% of major services (crowns, bridges, dentures), against an annual maximum usually between $1,000 and $2,000. Orthodontia is a separate rider, usually with a lifetime maximum.

Employers frequently make dental voluntary — the employee pays the full premium through payroll deduction — and still get most of the retention benefit, because group rates beat anything an individual can buy alone.

Group vision insurance

Vision is the cheapest coverage on this list, often a few dollars per employee per month. A typical plan covers an annual exam with a modest copay and provides an allowance toward frames or contacts every 12 or 24 months. Like dental, it is commonly offered voluntary.

Small coverage, but employees use it every year, which means they notice it every year.

Group life and AD&D

Basic group term life is usually employer-paid at either a flat amount ($25,000 or $50,000 are common) or a multiple of salary, most often one or two times annual earnings. Accidental death and dismemberment is typically bundled with it at little additional cost.

Two things worth knowing. First, employer-paid coverage above $50,000 creates imputed income that has to run through payroll — a routine compliance item that small employers miss regularly. Second, group term life is generally issued without medical underwriting up to a guaranteed issue limit, which makes it genuinely valuable to employees who would struggle to buy individual coverage.

Supplemental and dependent life can be layered on as voluntary options.

Short-term and long-term disability

Disability coverage replaces income when an employee cannot work. It is the coverage employees understand least and need most.

Short-term disability typically replaces 60% of income for a period of 12 to 26 weeks, beginning after a short elimination period. Michigan does not have a state disability program, which makes employer-sponsored STD more meaningful here than in states that do.

Long-term disability picks up where STD ends and can run to age 65 or to Social Security normal retirement age, usually replacing 60% of income up to a monthly cap.

Note the tax treatment, because it is counterintuitive and it matters: if the employer pays the premium, benefits are taxable to the employee. If the employee pays with after-tax dollars, benefits are tax-free. For a highly compensated group, having employees pay the LTD premium is often the better outcome even though it looks less generous on paper.

---

Tax-advantaged accounts: HSAs, FSAs, HRAs, ICHRA and QSEHRA

These are not insurance, but they sit alongside the health plan and change its economics.

Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) pair with a qualifying high-deductible health plan. Contributions are pre-tax, growth is tax-free, and withdrawals for qualified medical expenses are tax-free. The account belongs to the employee and follows them when they leave. Employer contributions to employee HSAs are a common way to soften the move to a higher deductible.

Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs) let employees set aside pre-tax dollars for medical or dependent care expenses. Funds are generally use-it-or-lose-it, subject to a limited carryover or grace period if the plan allows one.

Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs) are employer-funded accounts that reimburse employees for qualified expenses. Two variants are specifically designed for small employers:

• QSEHRA is available to employers with fewer than 50 full-time-equivalent employees who do not offer a group health plan. The employer sets an allowance, employees buy individual coverage, and the employer reimburses tax-free up to the annual limit.
• ICHRA has no size limit and can be offered alongside a group plan for different classes of employees. The employer defines an allowance by class; employees buy individual market coverage and are reimbursed.

ICHRA in particular has drawn real interest from Michigan employers with geographically dispersed workforces, where no single network serves everyone well. It is not automatically cheaper, and it moves plan selection onto the employee, which some workforces welcome and others resent. It is worth modeling rather than assuming.

---

Voluntary and worksite benefits

Accident, critical illness, hospital indemnity and legal plans cost the employer nothing beyond the payroll deduction and the administrative setup. They fill gaps left by high-deductible health plans and let employees self-select coverage that matches their circumstances.

The caution is menu fatigue. A benefits fair with fourteen options produces lower participation than one with four. Add voluntary lines deliberately, not because a carrier offered them.

---

Compliance: the part that generates penalties

This is where small employers get hurt, because none of it is visible until it is expensive.

• ERISA. Most employer-sponsored health and welfare plans are ERISA plans. That means a written plan document, a Summary Plan Description distributed to participants, and for plans with 100 or more participants, an annual Form 5500. Late 5500 filings accrue penalties per day.
• ACA employer mandate. At 50 or more full-time-equivalent employees you are an Applicable Large Employer, and you must offer minimum essential coverage that is affordable and provides minimum value, then report it on Forms 1094-C and 1095-C. The FTE calculation catches employers by surprise — part-time hours aggregate.
• COBRA. At 20 or more employees, you must offer continuation coverage and issue notices on a strict timetable. Missed notices are a common and avoidable liability.
• Section 125. Pre-tax payroll deductions require a written cafeteria plan document. Many small employers deduct pre-tax without ever adopting one.
• Michigan Earned Sick Time Act. Michigan’s ESTA changed accrual and usage rules for most employers and interacts with benefits eligibility, particularly for variable-hour staff. Worth a specific review if you have not done one.

None of this is exotic. All of it is routine when someone owns it, and expensive when nobody does.

---

What about property, liability and workers’ compensation?

Honest answer: those are real needs, and we do not handle them.

---

Building the package: what employers of each size typically do

Under 10 employees. Group health if the budget allows, often with a defined employer contribution toward employee-only coverage. Voluntary dental and vision. QSEHRA is a legitimate alternative if a group plan does not pencil out.

10 to 50 employees. Group health, increasingly level-funded. Employer-paid basic life. Voluntary dental, vision and disability. Section 125 plan in place. This is the range where a real broker starts paying for itself in multi-carrier bidding.

50 to 150 employees. ACA mandate applies, so reporting infrastructure matters. Level-funded or early self-funded. Employer-paid life and LTD become standard. Benefits administration technology becomes worth the cost. Executive carve-outs and MERPs are common for retaining leadership.

150 and up. Self-funding with stop-loss, dedicated benefits administration, and annual benchmarking against peer employers in your industry and region.

---

How a benefits broker earns their keep

An independent broker is paid by the carrier, not by you, which means the value has to show up somewhere else. It shows up in four places:

1. Multi-carrier bidding. Going to market with a clean census across every carrier that writes in your region, every year, rather than accepting the renewal.
2. Plan design. Adjusting deductibles, copays, contribution strategy and funding model to hit a budget without gutting the plan.
3. Compliance. Owning the 5500s, the COBRA notices, the ACA reporting and the plan documents so they are not on your HR person’s desk at 11pm.
4. Advocacy. Handling the claim that got denied, the enrollment that did not process, the ID card that never arrived.

Ask a prospective broker how many carriers they quoted last year, who handles your compliance filings, and what happens when an employee has a claim problem. The answers separate brokers quickly.

---

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to offer health insurance to my Michigan employees? Not if you have fewer than 50 full-time-equivalent employees. At 50 or more, the ACA employer mandate applies and non-compliance carries per-employee penalties.

What does group health cost a small Michigan employer? It varies with your census, region, plan design and funding model, which is why any number quoted without seeing your employee list is a guess. What we can say is that the spread between the best and worst quote for the same group is routinely large enough to matter, which is the argument for bidding it properly.

Can I offer benefits to some employees and not others? Yes, within limits. You can define classes based on legitimate employment criteria — full-time versus part-time, salaried versus hourly, geography — but the classes must be applied consistently and non-discrimination rules apply, particularly for self-funded plans and for highly compensated employees.

Is level funding risky for a small employer? The downside is capped by the stop-loss layer, so the worst case is a known number rather than an open-ended one. The real risk is being sold level funding when your group’s health profile does not support it. That is a diligence question, not a product question.

---

Talk to a Michigan benefits broker

CFH Insurance Consultants is an independent employee benefits brokerage serving Michigan employers. We have been placing and managing group benefits since 2007 — nearly two decades of renewals, plan changes and compliance cycles in this state.

We will review your current plan, your renewal and your compliance posture, and tell you plainly whether you are being served well. If you are, we will say so.

Sunny Connolly
Sr. Partner & Head of Growth and Partnerships
CFH Insurance Consultants
41000 Woodward Avenue, Suite 350 East, Bloomfield Hills, MI 48304

Call 248.370.8853 or book a 30-minute review.