Virtual-First Health Plans: How They Work And What To Check Before You Offer One
A virtual-first plan sends members to a virtual primary care visit before anything else and prices that choice into the benefit. It can lower cost and speed up access for some workforces, and it creates design, legal and communication questions that a standard plan does not. Here is how to evaluate one.
What To Weigh.
General information, not legal or tax advice. Check the cited sources before you act.
Michigan Telemedicine Coverage Law
What MCL 500.3476 requires of insurers and what it allows.
HDHP Telehealth Safe Harbor
How pre-deductible telehealth fits a health savings account plan.
Telehealth Savings Calculator
Estimate what shifting visits to virtual care could change.
A Plan Built Around A Virtual First Step.
A virtual-first plan, sometimes called a telehealth-first or telemedicine-first product, asks the member to start with a virtual primary care clinician. That clinician handles routine and many urgent needs and refers the member to in-person care, specialists and imaging when a visit cannot be done remotely. The plan usually rewards the virtual step with lower or no cost sharing for those visits and sometimes with a lower premium.
It is different from a telehealth benefit added on top of a standard plan. In that case virtual visits are one more option. In a virtual-first design the virtual visit is the front door, and the benefit design and the network are organized around it.
What State Law Says About Telemedicine Coverage.
Michigan law, MCL 500.3476, bars an insurer from requiring face-to-face contact for services that are appropriately provided through telemedicine. When a service is delivered by telemedicine, the insurer must provide at least the same coverage as for the in-person service. Copayments, coinsurance, deductibles and approved amounts still apply.
The same section lets an insurer require a provider to deliver telemedicine only through a contract with an affiliated provider or a third-party vendor for telemedicine-first or telemedicine-only products, and only where clinically appropriate. The provider must also be licensed or authorized in the state where the patient is located. As amended by 2024 PA 52, the section applies to policies delivered, issued, amended or renewed in Michigan and to out-of-state policies covering Michigan residents.
HSA Eligibility And Plan Documents.
If you offer a high-deductible health plan, telehealth coverage before the deductible no longer puts HSA eligibility at risk. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, enacted July 4, 2025, made the telehealth safe harbor permanent for plan years beginning after December 31, 2024, and IRS Notice 2026-5 gives further detail. Confirm with the carrier how a virtual-first design is classified before you pair it with an HSA.
A virtual-first benefit is still part of your group health plan. It belongs in the plan document and summary plan description, and it must meet the same federal rules as the rest of the plan, including the mental health parity comparisons for behavioral health delivered by video.
Who It Fits, And Who It Does Not.
Virtual-first designs tend to suit employers whose people are spread across locations, work shifts, or have limited time to take off for a primary care visit. They also suit employers with many young and generally healthy members who use little care.
They fit less well where members have established relationships with in-person doctors they want to keep, where dependents include young children whose needs are often in person, where broadband is unreliable, or where a large share of members live far from the plan’s in-person network. The right test is the member who needs care next month, not the average member.
Where To Begin.
Ask the carrier for the in-person network that backs the virtual clinicians, how referrals work, and what happens when a member already has a primary care doctor. Ask how the plan treats urgent needs, after-hours care and children.
Compare the member cost-sharing on virtual and in-person visits side by side, and check how the deductible interacts with the virtual step on both HSA-qualified and non-qualified versions of the plan.
Pilot the communication before the plan year. Employees who do not understand that the first call is a virtual visit will go straight to urgent care or the emergency room, which defeats the design.
Common Misreadings.
Telehealth-only coverage and virtual-first coverage are not the same thing. A plan that offers only virtual visits and nothing else is a limited benefit, and whether it can stand alone is a legal question to put to counsel before you offer it to anyone.
Savings come from avoided visits and lower unit costs, not from the label. Ask for the carrier’s own measured results for groups like yours and treat any projection as an estimate until you see your first claims experience.
A good virtual clinician does not replace a medical home for members with ongoing conditions. Make sure the design routes those members to in-person care without penalty.
Related Guides And Tools.
Telehealth Compliance In 2026
The state and federal rules that touch a telehealth benefit.
Direct Primary Care For Employers
Another way to build a front door for routine care.
Site Of Care Guide
How emergency room, urgent care and telehealth choices differ in cost.
Laws And Sources
26 U.S.C. 223: Health savings accounts and the high-deductible health plan rules.
IRS Notice 2026-5: Guidance on health savings account changes under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, including the telehealth safe harbor.
MCL 500.3476: Michigan telemedicine coverage parity.
ERISA Section 712, 29 U.S.C. 1185a: Mental health parity requirements for group health plans.
General information, not legal or tax advice. Check the cited sources before you act.
Quick Answers.
Short replies on this page’s topic, each tied to a fuller guide.
What is a virtual-first health plan?
A plan that asks members to start with a virtual primary care visit and then refers them to in-person care when needed, usually with lower cost sharing for the virtual step.
Does Michigan law require coverage of telemedicine?
MCL 500.3476 requires insurers to cover appropriately delivered telemedicine at least at the same level as the in-person service, subject to the policy’s cost sharing. It also allows telemedicine-first and telemedicine-only products delivered through a contracted provider or vendor.
Can I pair a virtual-first plan with an HSA?
Pre-deductible telehealth no longer threatens HSA eligibility, because the safe harbor is now permanent for plan years beginning after December 31, 2024. Confirm with the carrier how the specific plan is classified.
Is a virtual-first plan the same as a telehealth benefit?
No. A telehealth benefit adds virtual visits to a standard plan. A virtual-first plan makes the virtual visit the first step and designs the benefit and network around it.
What should I ask a carrier before offering one?
Ask who the virtual clinicians are, what in-person network backs them, how referrals work, how children and existing doctors are handled, and what results the carrier has measured for similar groups.
More On Virtual Care And Plan Design.
Telehealth Compliance In 2026
Rules that apply to a telehealth benefit.
HDHP Telehealth Safe Harbor
The pre-deductible rules for HSA plans.
Direct Primary Care
A membership model for routine care.
Mental Health Benefits
Behavioral health delivered by video.
Employee Plan Comparison Calculator
Compare total cost across plan designs.
Why Employees Pick The Wrong Plan
The communication gap behind plan choice.
An independent employee benefits consulting firm. We look at the entire benefits program — cost, plan performance, risk and administration.
Switch to CFH. Unhappy with your broker? Your employees won’t notice. You will. →
Cookies on This Site
We use cookies to keep the site working properly and to understand how it is used. You can decline anything that is not essential. See our Privacy Policy for the detail.
- Essential — needed for the site to load and for you to move around it. These cannot be switched off.
- Analytics — tell us which pages get read, so we know what is worth writing more of.
- Advertising — set by third parties such as ad and social platforms to measure and target campaigns.