By Company SizeWhat We DoComplianceWho We ServeResourcesAboutOur MethodCareersClient Login
Client LoginSend Us Your Renewal
Broker questions

What Should You Do If Your Benefits Broker Stops Responding?

Keep the coverage running, find out what cannot wait, and make sure you hold your own documents. Then decide whether the relationship can be repaired or needs to change. None of it requires you to wait for a reply.

Send Us Your Renewal

The first week

Protect what has a date

Write down what is coming

List the renewal date, open enrollment dates, pending enrollments and terminations, and the compliance deadlines for the year. These are the items that cannot wait for a callback.

Keep premiums and enrollment moving

Pay the carrier invoice and process new hires and terminations through the carrier or enrollment platform directly. Coverage should not depend on whether your broker has answered.

Collect your own documents

Gather the current renewal, rate sheets, plan summaries, the census, contracts and the logins for carrier and enrollment portals. Many of these belong to you as the plan sponsor.

Document the gap

Keep the dates and wording of your requests and the lack of reply. If you later change brokers, or need to show that a missed deadline was not yours, a record helps.

Go to the carrier directly

Carriers have employer service lines and account teams. They can confirm your plan details, rates and deadlines without the broker. They usually cannot advise on strategy, but they can tell you what is due.

Escalate inside the firm

If one person has gone quiet, someone else at the firm may own the account. Ask for a manager or a named backup. A firm that cannot name one has told you something.

If the relationship cannot be repaired

How a broker change works

It can be done without drama and without a gap in coverage.

A letter, signed by you

Moving to a new broker is done with a broker of record letter signed by an authorized person at your company. It tells the carrier whom you have chosen.

The carrier acts on it

Each carrier has its own process and timing, and many give the current broker a short window to respond. Ask the new firm to confirm timing with each carrier before you sign.

Coverage continues

A broker change does not change your plan, your rates or your effective dates. Employees keep their coverage and their cards. What changes is who services the account.

Afterward

What to put in place so it does not happen again

A named team, not a name

Ask who covers the account when your main contact is out, and get a second name.

A calendar you both sign

Agree on renewal, enrollment and compliance dates in advance, with who owns each.

Access to your own data

Keep your own copies of plan documents, rates and portal logins, whatever the arrangement.

Questions answered

Questions employers ask when a broker goes quiet.

How long should we wait before looking at alternatives?

Not long, if something with a date is at risk. A missed callback in a quiet week is one thing. An unanswered renewal two months out is another. Set your own line, such as one escalation and one week, and keep to it.

Will changing brokers disrupt our coverage?

It should not. The plan, rates and effective dates stay as they are. The new firm coordinates timing with each carrier so nothing lapses.

Do we have to tell our current broker?

The broker of record letter is what the carrier acts on, and carriers commonly notify the current broker. A direct conversation first is courteous, but whether to have it is up to you.

Can our broker refuse to give us our plan documents?

Plan documents and carrier contracts belong to the plan sponsor, which is your company, and carriers can supply many of them directly. Internal broker workpapers are a different matter. If you meet resistance, put the request in writing and involve counsel if needed.

Is there a fee to leave?

Look at any services agreement you signed. Many brokerage arrangements are paid by commission from the carrier and carry no exit fee, but fee-based agreements may have a notice period. Read yours before you act.

What if the renewal is only weeks away?

Then the dates drive everything. Get the renewal from the carrier, ask a second firm to review it right away, and decide whether a change before the renewal or after it makes more sense. Both are possible, and timing varies by carrier.

Can a second firm help while we are still deciding?

Yes. Sharing your renewal for a review does not change your broker of record. It gives you an outside read while you decide what to do.

Ready? Upload your renewal, or talk it through with someone first. No cost, no obligation.

Talk to an Expert

General information, not legal advice. Plan-specific questions belong with ERISA counsel, and we will bring them in.


Book a 30-minute call