Auto dealerships: how to plan benefits for commissioned sales staff, technicians and managers.
How commission pay affects affordability, how service technicians and sales staff differ, how multi-rooftop groups are counted and how to keep technicians in a tight labor market. Written for the dealer principal or controller.
Commission Pay and Affordability
Sales pay is largely commission, which complicates the ACA affordability test.
Choose a Safe Harbor
Pick the affordability safe harbor deliberately and document it. The choices rely on different pay figures, so one may work better for salaried staff and another for commissioned or hourly roles. Model each class with your adviser, choose the approach, and keep the calculation on file in case you are asked to support it.
Technician Pay
Flat-rate pay makes hourly rates harder to define. A technician paid per job or flagged hour may have variable earnings, so an hourly rate for the test can be unclear. Ask your adviser which method suits the pay plan, and keep the pay records that support it.
Apply Consistently
Use the same method for each class. If you use more than one approach, apply each one to a defined class and keep the classes fixed for the plan year. Switching methods person by person invites errors and makes it harder to explain your decisions later.
Multiple Rooftops and Entities
Dealer groups often hold each store in its own entity.
Aggregate the Count
Entities under common ownership are counted together for the large employer test. Add up employees at each store and any related entity, including a parts or service company, even when each has its own payroll. Run the combined count before opening or buying another location, and ask your adviser to confirm the result.
One Plan or Several
Decide whether stores share a plan or hold separate ones. One plan often means simpler renewals and a larger pool, while separate plans can allow different terms by store. Compare administration, cost and employee impact before choosing, and make sure each participating entity is named in the plan paperwork.
Consistent Eligibility
Apply the same rules across rooftops where possible. Different waiting periods or hour rules at different locations confuse employees and can raise fairness questions. Publish one policy, train each store’s office manager on it, and revisit it whenever a new rooftop joins the plan.
Keeping Skilled Service Staff
Technicians are in short supply and are courted by competitors.
Benefit Competitiveness
Benefits are part of the pitch against other dealers and independent shops. Many technicians and sales staff weigh benefits when deciding where to work. Ask your team what matters most, such as lower premiums, plan choice or flexibility, and present your offer next to what other local employers provide.
Income Protection
Disability coverage matters in physical work. Long-term disability and similar coverage can protect pay when a technician cannot work. Review how the policy defines disability, what waiting period applies and how benefits are taxed, and ask the carrier to explain exclusions that matter in your trade.
Tools and Training Support
Education assistance can help technicians advance. Training programs can help retain technicians, but how they are treated for tax purposes depends on the program. Ask your tax adviser whether reimbursements are taxable and how to document them separately from the health plan.
Principal and Management Coverage
Owners and managers often want richer coverage.
Executive Design
Executive arrangements raise nondiscrimination issues. Plans that favor owners or highly paid managers can create testing and tax problems. Ask your adviser to review the design before you roll it out, and keep documentation showing how eligibility and contributions were set.
Classes in the Plan Document
Define manager and staff classes in the plan. Written classes make it clear who gets what, and should be based on job-related factors such as role or location. Have your adviser review them, and state the eligibility and employer contribution for each class in the document.
Owner Rules
Ownership structure affects how owners fit the plan. Owners and their relatives can be treated differently from employees for tax and eligibility purposes. Ask a tax adviser how your ownership structure affects your own coverage before you enroll, and keep the answer with your plan records.
Reducing Turnover
Sales turnover is high, and training is costly.
Waiting Period Choice
Use a waiting period within the legal limit. A longer wait can lower early turnover costs, but a very long one can cost you recruits. Choose a period that fits your hiring pattern and stay within the legal cap, and write the rule into the plan document.
Clear Enrollment
Short, plain enrollment materials work best. Employees who understand the plan are more likely to use it well. Offer a short guide, a one-page cost comparison and a time to ask questions, and give service and sales staff a single contact for follow-up.
Voluntary Benefits
Supplemental options broaden choice. Employee-paid options such as accident or supplemental coverage can add choice without raising employer cost. Explain what each does and does not cover, and confirm the enrollment rules and eligibility with the carrier or administrator first.
Details That Matter in the Showroom and Shop
Dealerships have pay and perk structures that affect benefits.
Guarantees, Draws and Commission
Draws and minimum guarantees change what counts as the pay figure for affordability. Document the treatment per class. Decide which pay figure applies to each class and apply it the same way every year. Involve payroll and your adviser, and review the treatment when the pay plan changes or when someone moves from a guaranteed to a commission role.
Demo Vehicles and Purchase Discounts
Vehicle perks are taxable fringe benefits handled by payroll, apart from the health plan. Whether and how much of a vehicle or discount perk is taxable depends on the arrangement, so ask your tax adviser. Keep the records payroll needs, and keep those perks separate from eligibility and contribution decisions for health coverage.
New, Used and Service Departments
Departments often have different pay plans. Define each class so eligibility and contribution rules are clear. Sales, service and parts staff are often paid in very different ways, so a single rule may not fit all of them. Write each class in the plan document and have your adviser confirm the contribution rules fit the pay plans.
The questions that come from dealerships.
Six questions dealer principals bring us about benefits.
How does commission pay affect affordability?
The safe harbor has to be chosen and documented.
Do all our stores count together?
Entities under common ownership are generally aggregated.
Can managers get better coverage?
Yes if the classes are defined and any tests are passed.
How do we keep technicians?
Benefits, income protection and training support help.
What waiting period should we use?
One within the 90-day limit.
Where should we start?
Review your pay plans and entity structure.
Ready? Send us your renewal, or talk it through with someone first. No cost, no obligation.
General information for dealerships, not legal or tax advice. Pay plans and entity structure are fact-specific, so confirm yours with your adviser.
Related guides.
Mortgage Lenders and Financial Services
Benefits when pay is commission-based and headcount swings.
Auto Dealership Employee Benefits
Benefits for dealerships.
ACA Affordability Calculator
Test contributions against the affordability limits.
Executive Benefits and Highly Compensated Employees
Offering executives more within the rules.
Benefits Handled by Our Finance Team
When finance owns the decision, the questions are cost drivers, funding and predictability. See how to evaluate a renewal and plan ahead.
Where the Rules Come From.
The laws and rules named on this page link to the statute or regulation they come from. This is general information, not legal or tax advice, and rules change, so check the current text.
Affordable Care Act (Public Law 111-148)
The 2010 health reform law, with later amendments, behind employer coverage, reporting and market rules.
Send us your renewal.
We’ll tell you whether it looks competitive, where we see opportunity, and the five questions we’d put to your carrier. No cost, and no obligation to move anything.
The renewal letter
Your current plan summary
Contribution split by tier
Enrolled counts by tier
Four documents — two more if your group is 50 or more. Nothing else; every extra one is a reason to postpone.
An independent employee benefits consulting firm. We look at the entire benefits program — cost, plan performance, risk and administration.
Switch to CFH. Unhappy with your broker? Your employees won’t notice. You will. →
Cookies on This Site
We use cookies to keep the site working properly and to understand how it is used. You can decline anything that is not essential. See our Privacy Policy for the detail.
- Essential — needed for the site to load and for you to move around it. These cannot be switched off.
- Analytics — tell us which pages get read, so we know what is worth writing more of.
- Advertising — set by third parties such as ad and social platforms to measure and target campaigns.