Decision support and plan-selection education: helping employees choose a plan that fits them.
Why employees choose poorly without help, what good decision support looks like, how plan-fit calls and online tools fit together and how to measure whether it worked. Written for the owner or HR lead.
Most Employees Choose With Too Little Information
Plan choices have real dollar consequences, and many employees spend only minutes on them.
Defaulting to Last Year
Many employees keep their plan without checking whether it still fits their family or the year ahead. Life changes such as a new baby, a spouse’s new job or a doctor leaving a network can make last year’s plan a poor fit. A short prompt at enrollment asking employees to confirm their family, doctors and prescriptions catches many of these gaps before they become claims. You can test your own figures with our employee plan comparison calculator.
Choosing on Premium Alone
The lowest paycheck cost can mean the highest bill when care is needed. Employees often do not see the trade-off. A plan with a low premium often carries a high deductible, so a single hospital stay or specialist visit can cost far more than the premium savings. Show employees a realistic claim example next to the payroll deduction so the full cost is visible.
Wants Versus Needs
Employees often ask for a PPO they would not need. Most doctors take both an HMO and a PPO from the same carrier, so a good explanation can serve many of them. Help employees see the downside with our out-of-pocket exposure calculator.
Online Decision Tools
A decision tool asks a few questions and estimates total yearly cost for each option.
What They Estimate
Premium, expected use and out-of-pocket exposure combine into an estimated yearly cost per plan. Employees enter their expected doctor visits, prescriptions and any planned care, and the tool compares the plans side by side. The result is an estimate, not a quote, but it gives people a far clearer basis for choosing than premium alone.
Where They Live
Many benefits administration systems offer a decision support module for medical plans. Ask your administrator what is available. Employees usually reach it during online enrollment, right when they pick a plan. Confirm it is switched on, that the plan data behind it is current, and that employees know it exists, since an unused tool helps no one.
Their Limits
A tool depends on the answers employees give. It supports a choice but does not replace advice. If an employee guesses low on expected care or forgets a family member’s prescription, the estimate will be off. Remind people to enter their real situation and to treat the result as one input alongside plan summaries and a conversation with someone who knows the plans.
Plan-Fit Calls and Enrollment Support
Some employees need to talk to a person, especially families and anyone with ongoing care.
One-to-One Calls
A call with a benefits professional lets an employee match a plan to their doctors, prescriptions and budget. These calls work best when scheduled before the enrollment deadline, with a reminder to have prescription names and preferred providers on hand. They are especially useful for employees with ongoing conditions or a family choosing between very different plans.
Group Meetings
Short sessions explain the choices, with time for questions. Offer them at different times for shift workers. Keep the presentation short and plain, use a few common household examples, and leave time for questions. Record or summarize the session so remote and part-time employees who miss it can still get the same information.
Education Is an Investment
The cost of helping employees choose well is small compared with the cost of a poor fit. A poor fit can show up as employees who skip care because of an unexpected deductible, or who feel misled about what their coverage pays. Time spent on clear education up front often reduces those problems and the HR questions that follow.
Messages That Help People Decide
Clear communication makes the tools and calls work.
Lead with Decisions, Not Terms
Frame the enrollment around the choice employees have to make, with examples of different household situations. For example, show how a single employee, a couple and a family with children might each weigh the same plans differently. Plan terms like deductible and coinsurance can then be explained as they come up, instead of as a glossary employees will not read.
Show the Total Cost
Present premium and likely out-of-pocket cost together so low premiums do not mislead. Include a simple worked example for each plan, such as a routine year and a year with a significant claim. Employees can then see which option protects them better and which one costs less only when they stay healthy.
Make the Deadline Plain
State the enrollment window and what happens if nobody acts. Put the last day to enroll in every message, and say clearly whether current elections carry over or coverage lapses without a response. Confirm with your administrator how late changes are handled, since mid-year changes are generally limited to qualifying life events.
Did Decision Support Work?
Look at what employees did, not just how many logged in.
Participation in Tools and Calls
Track how many employees used a tool or a call, and which groups did not. Low usage in a particular location, shift or job group often points to a communication gap rather than disinterest. Use that information to adjust timing, format or language for the next enrollment, and follow up with employees who have not yet made a choice.
Plan Mix Shifts
Watch for movement between plans, and make sure it matches employee needs. A large move toward the highest deductible option, for example, may mean employees are chasing a lower paycheck cost without understanding the risk. Review the shift after enrollment and follow up where it looks out of line with household needs.
Questions After Enrollment
Fewer complaints about surprise bills usually means the education worked. Track the questions HR receives in the first few months, especially about claims, bills and which providers are covered. Recurring themes show what the next enrollment communication should explain better, and which plan details need a plainer description.
The questions that come from plan selection.
Six questions employers bring us about decision support.
What is decision support?
Tools and personal help that let employees compare plans on estimated total yearly cost.
Can employees get a personal call?
Yes. Plan-fit calls with a benefits professional are a common way to support families and anyone with ongoing care.
Does it replace advice?
No. It helps employees decide, but they remain responsible for their choices.
Do doctors take both HMO and PPO plans?
Often. Check the specific providers, because networks differ by plan.
How do we reach shift workers?
Offer sessions at different times and keep materials short and mobile-friendly.
How do we know it worked?
Track tool and call use, plan shifts and post-enrollment questions.
Ready? Send us your renewal, or talk it through with someone first. No cost, no obligation.
General information about enrollment education, not legal or tax advice. Employees remain responsible for their own choices, and education should not be presented as a guarantee of savings.
Related guides.
Wellness Incentives and Tobacco Surcharges
Reward limits and the alternatives a plan must offer.
Language Access and Benefits Communication
Reaching employees who read and speak other languages, and what the translation rules require.
Transition of Care When Changing Carriers
Keeping employees in treatment from being disrupted by a network or formulary change.
Waivers and Opt-Out Payments
Handling employees who decline coverage, participation math and opt-out payment rules.
Plan Types Guide
How HMO, PPO and HDHP plans differ.
Enrollment Support
Help for employees during enrollment.
Open Enrollment Project
Running enrollment from planning to close.
Send us your renewal.
We’ll tell you whether it looks competitive, where we see opportunity, and the five questions we’d put to your carrier. No cost, and no obligation to move anything.
The renewal letter
Your current plan summary
Contribution split by tier
Enrolled counts by tier
Four documents — two more if your group is 50 or more. Nothing else; every extra one is a reason to postpone.
An independent employee benefits consulting firm. We look at the entire benefits program — cost, plan performance, risk and administration.
Switch to CFH. Unhappy with your broker? Your employees won’t notice. You will. →
Cookies on This Site
We use cookies to keep the site working properly and to understand how it is used. You can decline anything that is not essential. See our Privacy Policy for the detail.
- Essential — needed for the site to load and for you to move around it. These cannot be switched off.
- Analytics — tell us which pages get read, so we know what is worth writing more of.
- Advertising — set by third parties such as ad and social platforms to measure and target campaigns.