The group plan caps its benefit, so the better someone is paid, the less of their income it actually replaces.
Group life and disability are built for the median employee: a percentage of salary up to a flat or monthly maximum, often on base pay only. For executives, owners and high earners that maximum arrives early and the bonus may not count at all. We measure the real gap for each person and decide what should fill it, and who should pay for it.
Three plan provisions quietly shrink coverage at the top.
None is a flaw. They are what keeps a group plan affordable, so the people they cut off need a separate answer.
The Benefit Maximum
Group long-term disability pays a percentage of covered pay up to a monthly cap. Above the cap every raise adds nothing to the benefit, so a senior employee’s real replacement ratio is often far below the plan’s headline percentage. Supplemental disability insurance for executives closes that gap.
The Definition of Earnings
Many policies define covered earnings as base salary. For a sales leader or an owner paid largely through bonus, commission or distributions, the benefit is calculated on a fraction of actual income so we read the definition before the rate. You can test your own figures with our group life insurance premium calculator.
The Guaranteed Issue Limit
Group life above a set amount requires evidence of insurability. The executive who most needs the higher amount is often the one most likely to be delayed or declined, so we time applications to an enrollment window rather than a mid-year promotion. Try our free life insurance needs calculator to run the numbers for your own group.
Who pays the premium decides whether the benefit arrives taxed.
Under IRS rules, disability benefits from a plan the employer pays for are taxable income to the employee, while benefits from a policy the employee paid for with after-tax dollars are not. Group life has its own rule: employer-provided group-term coverage above $50,000 creates imputed income.
Employer-Paid Disability
It is the most generous-looking option and produces the smallest check at claim time, because the benefit is taxed exactly when income has stopped. We show the after-tax benefit next to the premium, so the comparison is honest. After-tax comparisons make disability plan design decisions clearer.
Employee-Paid or Grossed-Up
Shifting the premium to the executive, or paying a taxable bonus to cover it, keeps the eventual benefit tax-free. The right choice depends on the company’s tax position and the individual’s, which a CPA available through us weighs in on.
Imputed Income on Life
Raising group-term life for executives adds imputed income to every paycheck, valued from the IRS premium table by age. For older executives that cost can rival an individual policy, so we compare both before raising the group amount. Comparing imputed income with an individual policy keeps executive life insurance cost-effective.
Supplemental coverage should be designed around what happens at a claim and at a departure.
The layer above the group plan is usually individual coverage the employer sponsors for a defined class.
Individual Disability on Top
An individual policy fills the space between the group cap and a sensible replacement target, and can carry own-occupation language the group plan lacks. Offered to a defined class, it can often be issued with reduced medical underwriting. Individual disability insurance on top of the group plan protects high earners. For a quick estimate, use our free age-rated premium calculator.
Integration with the Group Plan
Supplemental disability has to sit on top of group coverage without triggering its offset or overinsurance provisions, because a policy that reduces the group benefit has bought nothing. Careful integration keeps supplemental disability coverage worth what it costs, for the executive and the company.
Life Coverage That Travels
Group life usually ends, or converts on expensive terms, when employment ends. An individually owned policy stays with the executive, so we decide at the outset whether that portability is a reward or a retention problem. Portable life insurance is a design choice worth making on purpose.
What Voluntary Life Insurance Is and Who It Fits
Voluntary life lets employees buy extra term coverage through the workplace, usually by payroll deduction. It works best when it is designed and explained, not just offered.
Employee-Paid Term Coverage
Voluntary life is group term coverage the employee pays for. It sits on top of any employer-paid basic benefit and gives people a way to raise coverage to fit a mortgage, children or other obligations. Because employees decide whether to buy, clear examples of how much coverage different households might need matter more than any sales push.
Why Employers Offer It
It adds a meaningful benefit with little or no employer premium cost. For many employees it is the easiest way to buy life insurance, since there is no separate application with an agent, at least up to the guarantee issue amount.
Who Tends to Use It
Employees with dependents, debts or a single household income often have the largest gap between basic life and what their families would need. We help employers describe the benefit in those terms, without scare tactics. Younger families and single-income households are often the groups to speak to first.
Group Versus Individual Policies
Group voluntary coverage is convenient and often guaranteed up to a limit, but it is usually term coverage that ends with employment unless portability or conversion applies. Individual policies belong to the person. We help employees understand both. Ask each carrier what portability or conversion rights apply so employees can decide with the full picture.
Where It Fits in the Package
Voluntary life is one of several employee-paid lines that complete a benefits menu. See our overview of voluntary and ancillary benefits and our group life insurance page.
A Compliance Note
Whether a voluntary program is an ERISA plan depends on the employer’s level of involvement. Fully employee-paid programs may qualify for a Department of Labor safe harbor if the employer’s role is limited. We flag this for the employer’s counsel to confirm.
Election Amounts, Increments, and Employee Rates
The structure of the election menu shapes what employees actually buy.
Increments and Maximums
Plans set an election increment, such as $10,000 or $25,000, and a maximum, often stated as a dollar cap or a multiple of salary. Employees choose a level within those limits.
Age-Banded Employee Rates
Voluntary life is commonly priced by age bracket, so rates rise as employees move into the next band. Employees should see their own rate per $1,000 before they elect. Providing a rate chart in the enrollment materials, rather than quoting a single average, avoids confusion when employees compare options.
Tobacco Status
Some carriers price tobacco users separately and ask the employee to certify status. Employers should make sure the enrollment platform captures it, because a wrong answer can create a claim problem later. A short note on how the carrier defines tobacco use helps employees answer accurately.
Rate Guarantees
Ask how long rates are fixed and what could trigger a change. Rate guarantees for voluntary coverage often differ from those on the employer-paid base. Compare the guarantee period across carriers, and note whether a change in participation or group size could reopen the rates before the period ends.
Age Reductions
Voluntary coverage is commonly reduced at later ages under the carrier’s schedule. One carrier example reduces benefits to 65 percent at 70 and 50 percent at 75. Obtain the actual schedule before you present the plan.
A Clear Rate Illustration
We prepare a simple table showing the per-pay-period cost of each election for typical ages, so employees compare cost and coverage in plain numbers. Any figures in such materials come from the carrier’s filed rates. Employees tend to enroll with more confidence when they can see the cost per paycheck beside the coverage amount.
Guarantee Issue Windows, Evidence of Insurability, and Late Entrants
Underwriting rules are where voluntary life most often surprises employees.
The First Window
New hires who enroll during their initial eligibility period, commonly 31 days, can usually elect up to the guarantee issue amount without health questions. A carrier example allows $250,000 on that basis.
Above the Guarantee Issue Amount
Any amount above the limit requires evidence of insurability. The carrier reviews the health information and may approve, decline or offer a smaller amount. The employee pays nothing until it is approved. Tell employees early that the review takes time, and that coverage above the guaranteed amount does not begin until the carrier approves it.
Late Entrants
An employee who waits past the initial window generally must provide evidence of insurability for all amounts. The same is true for coverage added after a rate or plan change unless the employer arranges a special enrollment. A reminder to eligible employees before the initial window closes helps avoid this outcome.
Open Enrollment Increases
Raising an election at open enrollment often requires evidence of insurability, even for current participants. Some plans permit a small annual increase without it. Confirm the policy. Tell employees before open enrollment which increases are allowed without health questions, so they can plan their elections and the carrier’s forms arrive on time.
Qualifying Life Events
Some carriers allow election changes after marriage, birth or adoption. Whether these changes are guaranteed or need evidence of insurability depends on the carrier, so we ask. Make sure your enrollment platform and your HR team know the carrier’s rules and time limits, so employees who experience a life event can act promptly.
Why It Matters to Employers
Employees who are denied coverage after waiting may blame the employer. Clear communication before the window opens, and a reminder before it closes, protects the relationship. Written notices, a clear deadline and a follow-up for new hires give you a record of having told employees what was available.
Participation Requirements and Enrollment Practice
Carriers set requirements for voluntary plans. Missing them can affect the rates or even the offer.
Minimum Participation
Carriers often require a minimum number or percentage of eligible employees to enroll before voluntary rates and guarantee issue terms apply. The requirement is in the proposal, so ask for it in writing. Ask what counts as an eligible employee for this purpose, since the denominator affects whether you meet the minimum.
What Happens If It Is Missed
If participation falls short, the carrier may reduce guarantee issue amounts, change rates, or end the arrangement at renewal. We watch participation each year so the employer is not surprised. Ask the carrier what notice it gives you before any change, so there is time to boost enrollment.
Enrollment Method
Online enrollment with a decision tool tends to produce better participation than paper. Employees can see rates, try amounts and name beneficiaries in one session. We support enrollment through the employer’s platform. Employees who enroll remotely may still need help, so offer a short walk-through or a contact for questions.
Communication Plan
Short, plain messages sent before and during enrollment outperform one long presentation. Our page on reading your plan documents explains how we help employees understand what they are signing.
Payroll Setup
Deductions must match the elected amount and the correct rate for the employee’s age. Payroll should reconcile deductions to the carrier’s bill each month, since errors are hard to fix after a claim. A quick test with one pay cycle’s deductions before the plan goes live can catch setup errors.
Ongoing Administration
New hires, terminations, age-band changes and beneficiary updates all flow through the carrier bill. Careful record-keeping keeps coverage valid when a claim comes in. Assign one person on the employer side to review the bill each month and update records, so changes reach the carrier promptly.
Voluntary Spouse and Child Life Coverage
Family coverage is smaller and simpler, with a few rules worth knowing.
Spouse Coverage
Spouses can usually be covered in set amounts, often capped at a share of the employee’s own election. The spouse’s age typically determines the rate. Ask the carrier how spouse amounts relate to the employee’s election, and whether the employee can change them later without health questions.
Child Coverage
Child life is generally a flat benefit for all eligible children for a single low premium. Definitions of eligible children and age limits are in the certificate. Confirm how the plan treats stepchildren and adult children, so employees know who is eligible before they enroll.
The Employee Must Elect
Dependent coverage generally requires the employee to carry coverage. If the employee leaves, family coverage normally ends with it unless portability or conversion is available. Explain this to employees before they decide, particularly those who plan to rely on family coverage if they change jobs.
Health Questions for Dependents
Spouse amounts above a guarantee issue level may need evidence of insurability. Some plans also delay coverage if a dependent is confined or hospitalized on the effective date. Remind employees to read the effective date rules and ask HR if a family member is in the hospital near enrollment.
Tax Treatment
Employer-paid dependent coverage of $2,000 or less is treated by the IRS as a de minimis benefit. Voluntary coverage the employee pays for is a different situation, and your tax adviser should confirm the treatment.
Keep Eligibility Accurate
Records of who is covered should match who is eligible. See our guide to dependent eligibility verification for the practices we recommend.
Voluntary Accidental Death and Dismemberment
Voluntary AD&D is inexpensive and often misunderstood. Employees should know what it pays and what it does not.
What It Is
Voluntary AD&D pays if the employee dies in a covered accident and pays a percentage for covered losses such as limbs or sight. Employees choose an amount within the plan’s limits. Employees should see the amounts side by side with their other benefits so they can judge need.
Not Life Insurance
AD&D does not pay for death from illness. Because most deaths are not accidental, AD&D complements life coverage rather than replacing it. We make this distinction explicit in communications. Employees sometimes assume it replaces life coverage, so a short comparison in the guide helps them choose well.
Common Exclusions
Carrier AD&D materials commonly exclude losses from war, suicide or self-injury, committing a felony, sickness, and voluntary use of drugs or alcohol not as directed. Always check the specific certificate.
Timing Requirement
Carriers typically require that the loss occur within a set time of the accident, often 365 days, and result from the accident independent of other causes.
Family and Add-On Benefits
Family plans may include benefits for a spouse or children, and some include seat belt, air bag or education benefits. These extras vary and should be compared line by line. Ask the carrier for a side-by-side list of extras so employees are not paying for features they will not use.
Employee-Paid Tax Treatment
Ask your tax adviser how AD&D premiums and benefits are treated under your plan structure, since the answer depends on who pays and how the plan is set up. We are not tax or legal advisers.
Tax Treatment of Employee-Paid Group Term Life
The tax rules look at who carries the policy and how premiums are set. This summary is general, and your tax professional should confirm it for your plan.
The Employer-Carried Test
IRS guidance says the $50,000 exclusion rules apply when the employer carries the policy. If the policy is not employer-carried, the employee generally has no tax consequence from it.
The Straddle Test
Even if employees pay the full charged rate, IRS guidance describes a test where premiums are arranged so some employees subsidize others. If that applies, the benefit may be taxable using the IRS table rates.
What That Can Mean in Practice
For age-banded voluntary plans, younger employees may pay rates that differ from the IRS table, which is why carriers and payroll teams review it. Ask the carrier how it handles imputed income on voluntary coverage.
Employer-Paid Layers
Where the employer pays for basic coverage above $50,000, imputed income applies. Employee payments reduce the taxable amount. Our group life page walks through a hypothetical example.
Key Employee Testing
Employer-sponsored group-term life is subject to nondiscrimination rules in Section 79 for key employees. Voluntary plans open to all eligible employees are generally easier to defend. Have your adviser confirm.
Beneficiary Proceeds
Life insurance death benefits paid to a beneficiary are generally not taxable income to them, though special situations exist. Employees with larger estates should speak with their own tax or legal adviser.
Portability, Conversion, and Keeping Voluntary Coverage
Voluntary coverage is only as portable as the certificate allows. Employees need to hear this before they leave, not after.
Coverage Usually Ends
Group voluntary coverage normally ends when employment ends. An employee who wants to keep it generally needs to use a portability or conversion right and apply within the stated window. Give departing employees a short written notice of their options, with the deadline, as part of the exit process.
Portability
Portability continues group-style term coverage at the employee’s own expense. Carrier examples describe a 31-day application window, a good-health statement, and caps on amounts.
Conversion
Conversion turns group life into an individual policy without proof of health. Michigan law sets a 31-day application window after termination for conversion of group life coverage, and the certificate has the details. Converted premiums are higher.
What Is Left Behind
Conversion is for life coverage, not AD&D, and may omit group extras such as waiver of premium. Carrier examples show converted amounts cannot be increased later. Share this with employees who rely on voluntary coverage, since many are surprised to learn that the extras do not carry over.
Retirement and Reductions
Coverage may reduce or end at retirement. Employees nearing retirement should review options early, including individual coverage. Ask the carrier how reductions apply for employees who keep working past a typical retirement age, and give those employees a written summary so they can decide on other options in time.
What to Ask Carriers
Ask whether portability is offered, the maximum and minimum amounts, the deadline, how rates may change, and whether dependents can be included. Our group life page lists more carrier questions.
What employers ask about covering their executives.
Can we give richer coverage only to executives?
Individual policies outside the group plan can generally be offered to a defined class. Inside the group-term life plan it is different: Section 79 has nondiscrimination rules, and a plan that favors key employees can cost them the tax exclusion. Counsel confirms the route.
Will the executive have to answer medical questions?
Not always. Coverage offered to a whole class on a defined basis can often be issued with limited underwriting up to a set amount. Above that, individual underwriting applies, which is why we apply for the class together, not one person at a time.
What happens when the executive leaves?
An individually owned policy can usually be continued at the executive’s own cost. Whether that is a benefit you want to give is a design decision we make with you up front, not something discovered at the exit interview. Planning portability up front avoids surprises at an executive’s exit.
What is the difference between basic life and supplemental life?
Basic life is the employer-paid base amount, often a flat amount or a multiple of salary. Supplemental or voluntary life is extra coverage employees buy on top of it, usually at their own cost.
What is guaranteed issue?
It is the amount of coverage employees can elect without answering health questions, usually at their first eligibility. Amounts above it require evidence of insurability. The limits vary by carrier and group size.
Can employees cover a spouse or children?
Many carriers offer dependent coverage in smaller amounts, and the spouse amount is often tied to the employee amount. Availability and limits vary, so we confirm them during the carrier comparison.
Does employer-paid life create taxable income?
Employer-paid group term life above 50,000 dollars creates imputed income, which is reported as taxable wages using an IRS table. Coverage employees pay for themselves does not. See our group life guide for the full picture.
Does the benefit go down as employees get older?
Many group policies reduce the benefit amount at set ages, and rates often change by age band. Ask for the reduction schedule in writing before you compare prices.
Related guides.
Executive Benefits and Highly Compensated Employees
How to offer executives more within the nondiscrimination rules.
When an Employee Dies
The benefits steps that matter and their order.
Group Life and AD&D Plan Design
Benefit amounts, imputed income and portability.
Group-Term Life Imputed Income Under Section 79
How the $50,000 exclusion, IRS Table 2-2 rates, and W-2 code C reporting work.
Where the Rules Come From.
The laws and rules named on this page link to the statute or regulation they come from. This is general information, not legal or tax advice, and rules change, so check the current text.
ERISA (29 U.S.C. Chapter 18)
The federal law that sets reporting, disclosure and fiduciary rules for employer-sponsored benefit plans.
Send us your renewal.
We’ll tell you whether it looks competitive, where we see opportunity, and the five questions we’d put to your carrier. No cost, and no obligation to move anything.
The renewal letter
Your current plan summary
Contribution split by tier
Enrolled counts by tier
Four documents — two more if your group is 50 or more. Nothing else; every extra one is a reason to postpone.
An independent employee benefits consulting firm. We look at the entire benefits program — cost, plan performance, risk and administration.
Switch to CFH. Unhappy with your broker? Your employees won’t notice. You will. →