What Makes a Good Benefits Broker? A Guide for Michigan Employers
A good benefits broker holds your cost down at renewal and not only at the first quote, builds coverage around your workforce, speaks up for you when a carrier disagrees, and stays reachable all year. Those four tests matter more than the number on the first proposal, and each can be checked with a few questions before you sign.
Key takeaways
Judge a broker by the third renewal, not the first proposal. Coverage is placed once and renewed every year after.
Good coverage is tailored to your workforce, not padded. It starts with your census, plan documents and claims, not a template.
A good broker will tell you about a time they pushed back on a carrier for a client, and what came of it.
Ask how your broker is paid, in writing. For an ERISA group health plan, federal law already requires the disclosure.
What happens at renewal
Placement is a one-time event. The renewal is where the cost of your plan gets set, and it gets set again every year. A broker who wins on the first quote and then passes along each increase can cost you more over three years than one who started a little higher and held the line. Holding a number by quietly trimming benefits is not a win; it is a cut.
What good looks like
The broker shows you the carrier’s opening ask beside the final result, and tells you whether the plan design changed to get there.
A question to ask
“For a client like us, can you show the carrier’s opening renewal ask next to what was agreed, and what changed in the plan?”
Coverage built for your workforce
Comprehensive does not mean more. It means coverage that fits the people you employ: hourly or salaried, in one location or several, working on site or remotely. A good broker earns that fit by learning your business, and avoids selling you what you will not use.
What good looks like
The broker asks for your census, plan documents and claims experience before proposing anything, and explains why the design suits your employees.
A question to ask
“What would you need from us before you proposed a plan, and how would you use it?”
Who speaks up when the carrier disagrees
Coverage is only as good as the carrier’s willingness to pay. When a claim is disputed, an eligibility problem lands on an employee, or a renewal rests on a questionable assumption, you want a broker who works for you in that conversation and who anticipated the dispute by explaining the scope of coverage up front.
What good looks like
The broker can describe specific times they challenged a carrier on a client’s behalf, and what happened.
A question to ask
“Tell me about a time you pushed back on a carrier for a client. What did you do and what came of it?”
Whether you can reach them, and who answers
Service is what you feel every month. It includes how fast questions get answered, who handles an urgent claim escalation, how open enrollment runs, and the tone of the relationship. Plenty of brokers look the same on paper and differ completely here.
What good looks like
You know who is on your account, what response to expect, and who covers when your main contact is out.
A question to ask
“Who answers when my main contact is unavailable, and how quickly?”
How your broker is paid
Brokers are typically paid through commission built into the premium, a fee you pay directly, or a combination. None of these is wrong by itself. What matters is that you know which one applies and what else the broker may earn from carriers. For a group health plan covered by ERISA, a broker or consultant who expects to receive $1,000 or more in direct or indirect compensation must disclose it in writing to the plan fiduciary before the arrangement is entered into, extended or renewed (ERISA section 408(b)(2)(B), 29 U.S.C. § 1108(b)(2)(B)).
What to ask for
The written disclosure, including any compensation from carriers beyond the commission on your own plan.
Why it matters
Compensation shapes incentives. Knowing it lets you compare proposals on the same footing.
How we answer these four tests
A team on your account
For proper coverage of an account we work in teams of 5: an account executive, an account manager, a plan analyst, customer service and IT. If one person is out, your account is still covered.
Decisions made by the people doing the work
Our service teams decide what technology, software and data access an account needs, including bringing in more people, and the firm supports the decision.
Experts behind the team
Clients can reach CPAs and attorneys through the firm, and our chat assistant is available 24/7 for benefits questions.
Narrowing the field
Write down your top three priorities. The best broker for a 40-person firm and for a multi-location mid-market employer are not always the same.
Put the four questions above to two or three brokers and compare the answers, not the first quotes.
Ask each broker for the written compensation disclosure.
If you already have a renewal in hand, have us review it and see how it reads against these tests.
Questions we get
What is the downside of using a broker?
Quality varies, and incentives differ depending on how the broker is paid. That is why the compensation disclosure and the four tests above are worth asking for before you sign.
Is a bigger broker a better broker?
Not by itself. Size can bring data and carrier leverage, and it can also mean your account is a small one on a large desk. Ask who will actually work on your account.
How many brokers should I talk to?
Two or three is usually enough to compare. Ask each the same questions so the answers are comparable.
Can I change brokers during the plan year?
A broker of record letter is how the change is made, and carriers generally accept one outside renewal, though timing and effective dates vary by carrier. See our guide to the broker of record letter.
Does a better broker mean a lower renewal?
Not always. A good broker can show you what drove the increase and which levers exist, and sometimes the honest answer is that the renewal is already competitive.
Is this legal advice?
No. This page is general information, not legal advice. Rules change and facts differ, so confirm your situation with your attorney or tax advisor.
The law behind this page.
ERISA section 408(b)(2)(B), added by the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021, section 202 (29 U.S.C. § 1108(b)(2)(B)).
Send us your renewal.
We’ll tell you whether it looks competitive, where we see opportunity, and the five questions we’d put to your carrier. No cost, and no obligation to move anything.
The renewal letter
Your current plan summary
Contribution split by tier
Enrolled counts by tier
Four documents — two more if your group is 50 or more. Nothing else; every extra one is a reason to postpone.
An independent employee benefits consulting firm. We look at the entire benefits program: cost, plan performance, risk and administration.
Switch to CFH. Unhappy with your broker? Your employees won’t notice. You will. →