Renewal Second Opinion

A second opinion on your health insurance renewal.

Your renewal arrived with a number and a recommendation. Before you sign, have someone with no stake in the answer check the math, the market and the plan. We review renewals for Michigan employers at no cost and put what we find in writing.

Send Us Your Renewal

The Short Answer

Should you get a second opinion on your health insurance renewal?

Usually, yes. A renewal is the carrier’s opening number, not a final price, and the person recommending you accept it is often the broker who placed the plan. A second opinion checks what the renewal letter does not show: whether the increase matches your carrier’s state filing or your own claims, whether anyone priced the plan anywhere else, and whether the plan quietly changed.

See the approved 2027 increases by carrier →

When It Is Worth It

A double-digit increase, a recommendation to accept as offered, plan changes you did not ask for, or no market check in three years. In 2027, approved Michigan small-group increases range from 7.0% to 14.8% by carrier, so the carrier you are with matters as much as the number. If your broker was recently acquired, see what to check after a broker acquisition.

When It Is Not

Your increase came in below trend and the market was tested. If that is what we find, we say so in writing, and you renew knowing the number is fair. Even then, we show the work behind that conclusion so you can see how the number was tested.

We don’t control whether a renewal opens up or down. That is your claims experience or your carrier’s state filing. We control whether the number you are given is the number you accept.

What We Check

Six things a second opinion looks at before anything else.

Most of what goes wrong in a renewal is visible in the documents you already have. We start there, not with a sales pitch.

The Arithmetic

Rates times enrolled counts, tier by tier, should equal the premium the carrier states. When they do not tie, a rate was mistyped or a count is wrong, and it gets fixed before anyone negotiates anything. Checking this early leaves time to request a corrected rate sheet. Line up competing quotes side by side with our free health plan quote comparison calculator.

Whether the Increase Fits Your Size

Under 50 employees, small-group rates are community-rated and filed with the state, so the question is whether another plan or carrier filed lower, not whether the rate can be talked down. Above 50, your own claims start to count. Our page on double-digit renewals explains how to take the number apart.

What the Market Was Actually Asked

Which carriers were approached, on what census, and which declined or never quoted. “We shopped it” is not an answer; a list of carriers and their responses is. Asking for that list also shows whether the market was truly tested or only lightly sampled, and which carriers might still be approached. You can test your own figures with our multi-year renewal increase calculator.

Plan Design and Contributions

Whether the same money buys a better-fitting plan, and whether the employee share still passes the ACA affordability test. The affordability calculator does that check in a minute.

What Is Missing

Claims experience, a large-claimant report, the carrier’s rate exhibit, and the written disclosure of what your broker is paid. Our page on how benefits brokers are paid covers that last one.

How Much Time Is Left

How many days remain before the decision is due, and what can still change in that window. Some levers need weeks; others, like correcting a rate error, need a phone call. Knowing the deadline early matters, because the options narrow quickly as the renewal date approaches. You can test your own figures with our broker compensation per employee calculator.

How It Works

Four steps, and nothing changes unless you decide it should.

A second opinion is a read, not a switch. Your plan, your carrier and your broker stay exactly where they are while we look.

Michigan chamber members: how the review works for you →

Step 1

Send What You Already Have

The renewal letter, your current plan summary, the contribution split by tier and enrolled counts by tier. At 50 or more employees, add the census and claims experience.

Step 2

We Read It

About seven days for groups of 2 to 50, fourteen for 51 to 250 and up to twenty-one above that, assuming a complete file.

Step 3

You Get It in Writing

What the renewal actually says, what we would question, and what we would do next, in plain language you can take to your leadership.

Step 4

You Decide

Keep the renewal as offered, go back to your broker with our questions, or work with us. Any of the three is a good outcome if it is an informed one.

When It Matters Most

A second opinion earns its keep in these situations.

Any renewal can be reviewed, but these are the ones where a fresh read most often changes the outcome. If you are weighing a renewal line by line yourself, start with the first two.

A Double-Digit Increase

Especially when the only explanation offered is “trend” or “your claims were high.” If pharmacy is the driver, our GLP-1 coverage guide shows where that spend comes from.

A Recommendation to Accept as Offered

Sometimes that is the right call. It should come with the evidence that the market was tested. Accepting can be sensible when the increase is reasonable, plan design is intact and alternatives were compared on equal terms. What matters is that the decision rests on a documented comparison rather than on a lack of time or options.

Plan Changes You Did Not Ask For

Carriers retire plans and map groups to new ones. The replacement can carry a higher deductible or a narrower network at the same price. Reading the renewal documents closely, and comparing the new plan to the old on deductible, coinsurance and network, shows whether the change is minor or material before employees are affected.

You Crossed 50 Employees

Pricing, reporting and the ACA employer mandate all change at once. Our crossing fifty guide covers what moves.

The First Renewal After a Large Claim

How the carrier weighs one bad year depends on your size and credibility, and it is worth checking the math. Ask how the claim was treated in the rating, how much weight your own experience gets, and whether any pooling or large-claim charge was applied. A second look can show whether the carrier math is reasonable for a group your size.

No Market Check in Three Years

Rates, carriers and networks move. A plan that was right three years ago may not be the best fit now. A fresh comparison on the same census and plan design shows whether the current arrangement still earns its place, and gives you leverage at the table either way. Doing it before renewal terms arrive leaves more room to act.

Questions We Get

What employers ask before they send it.

These sit alongside the questions on our send us your renewal page, which covers cost, confidentiality and broker of record letters.

Will our current broker find out?

Not from us. We do not contact your broker. If we need information from the carrier, you sign a one-page authorization that lets the carrier release your group’s own data to us. It does not change who represents you.

Our rates are filed with the state. Can a second opinion still lower them?

The filed rate for a given small-group plan is the filed rate. What changes the cost is the choice of plan, carrier, network and contribution split, and whether the renewal was calculated correctly in the first place. Our Michigan benefits compliance page explains what the state regulates.

The renewal quietly changed our plan. How would we know?

Compare the renewal plan’s deductible, out-of-pocket maximum, copays, network and pharmacy tier structure against your current summary of benefits and coverage, line by line. We do that comparison as part of every review.

Our broker says the market was tested. How do we check?

Ask for the list of carriers approached, the census they were sent, and each carrier’s written quote or declination. A real market check leaves a paper trail. For more like this, see the questions to ask a benefits broker.

Is it worth a second opinion if the increase is small?

Often, yes. A low increase can come from a plan downgrade, a benefit change or a network swap. The price is only half of what renewed.

We are level-funded or self-funded. Does this still apply?

Yes, and there is more to check: the stop-loss deductible and any lasers on individual members, the aggregate corridor, the fixed administration costs and how any surplus is returned.

Can you review dental, vision, life and disability too?

Yes. Those lines are usually priced from rate cards by group size, so shopping them is often quicker and the savings easier to confirm than on medical.

What if the renewal is fine?

Then you hear that in writing, with the reasons, and you keep it. Knowing your renewal is sound is a useful answer, and one you can show your leadership.

Do we have to change carriers to save money?

No. Many of the savings we find stay with the same carrier: a better-fitting plan, a different contribution split, a corrected rate or census, or a network that matches where your employees live. Our health and cost strategy work builds on the same levers.

Who at CFH actually does the review?

A plan analyst works the numbers and an account executive walks you through what they found. For proper coverage of an account we work in teams of five, so the people who review it are the people who would run it.

Ready? Send us your renewal, or talk it through with someone first. No cost, no obligation.

Talk to an Expert

General information about renewal reviews, not legal advice. Plan-specific questions belong with ERISA counsel, and we will bring them in.

Sources

Where the Rules Come From.

The laws and rules named on this page link to the statute or regulation they come from. This is general information, not legal or tax advice, and rules change, so check the current text.

ERISA (29 U.S.C. Chapter 18)

The federal law that sets reporting, disclosure and fiduciary rules for employer-sponsored benefit plans.

Read the Summary

Affordable Care Act (Public Law 111-148)

The 2010 health reform law, with later amendments, behind employer coverage, reporting and market rules.

Read the Summary

Let’s Get to Work

Send us your renewal.

We’ll tell you whether it looks competitive, where we see opportunity, and the five questions we’d put to your carrier. No cost, and no obligation to move anything.

What to send

The renewal letter
Your current plan summary
Contribution split by tier
Enrolled counts by tier

Four documents, two more if your group is 50 or more. Nothing else; every extra one is a reason to postpone.

CFH Insurance Consultants

An independent employee benefits consulting firm. We look at the entire benefits program — cost, plan performance, risk and administration.

Switch to CFH. Unhappy with your broker? Your employees won’t notice. You will. →

Michigan41000 Woodward Avenue, Suite 350 East
Bloomfield Hills, MI 48304
248.370.8853
Colorado13540 Northgate Estates, Suite 100
Colorado Springs, CO 80921
719.425.2649
Texas16365 Park Ten Place, Suite 182
Houston, TX 77084
281.404.5670

Book a 30-minute call