The economic reality test asks whether the worker depends on you or is in business for themselves.
The FLSA analysis asks what the working relationship really looks like, regardless of what the contract calls it. The sections below set out the factors and urge caution in applying them.
The factors in the test.
Consider this an introduction, not counsel. Since the Labor Department has rewritten its classification rule several times, make sure you are reading the version now in force.
Opportunity for Profit or Loss
Whether the worker can earn more or lose money through managerial skill, pricing or investment points toward contractor status.
Investment and Permanence
Substantial worker investment in equipment and an indefinite, exclusive relationship are weighed against each other.
Control and Integral Role
The degree of control over how, when and where work is done, and whether the work is part of the employer’s core business, both matter.
Applying the test.
The Labor Department’s regulation at 29 C.F.R. Part 795 sets out several factors weighed together, with none controlling. Because the agency’s enforcement stance has moved from one administration to the next, confirm which version is in force.
A written contractor agreement helps but does not control. If the worker is economically dependent in practice, a court can treat them as an employee regardless of the label.
Misclassification can bring back wages, overtime, penalties and tax liabilities, and it may expose the employer to claims that the worker should have been offered benefits.
Where this shows up in your plan.
Plan Eligibility Exposure
Where plan terms are loosely written, a worker later deemed an employee may argue for retroactive coverage. Precise eligibility wording reduces that risk.
ACA Exposure
For large employers, misclassified workers can count as full-time employees and raise penalty risk.
Reclassification Planning
If a worker is converted, plan the enrollment, waiting period and notice steps.
Setting it up.
List all contractors and describe each relationship.
Score each against the factors.
Reclassify any worker who is economically dependent.
Update contractor agreements to reflect reality.
Review plan documents for contractor exclusion language.
Mistakes to avoid.
Relying on a contractor label or a signed agreement alone.
Treating a long-term exclusive worker as a contractor.
Ignoring that different agencies use different tests.
Reclassifying without telling benefits counsel.
Other rules employers work with.
Independent Contractor and Joint Employer Guide
Return to the parent guide.
Worker Classification and Benefits Eligibility
Eligibility rules.
FLSA Salary Threshold
Related wage rules.
Laws and Rules Referenced
FLSA definitions, 29 U.S.C. 203 — Statutory definitions behind the economic reality analysis.
DOL classification rule, 29 C.F.R. Part 795 — Independent contractor status under the FLSA.
DOL: Employee or Independent Contractor — Agency guidance.
ACA mandate, 26 U.S.C. 4980H — The route by which a classification error can turn into an ACA penalty.
Quick answers.
Employers ask about worker classification in these terms most; each short reply leads to the full guide.
Does a signed contractor agreement settle it?
No. The relationship in practice controls.
Which test does Michigan use?
It depends on the claim. Federal wage law uses the economic reality test; other laws use different tests.
Can one worker be an employee for one law and a contractor for another?
Yes, different laws use different tests.
More guides in this series.
Common-Law Control Test for Employee Status and Plan Eligibility
A companion guide in the same series.
Joint Employment and Controlled Group Rules for Benefit Plans
A companion guide in the same series.
Plan Eligibility Language for Contractors and Reclassified Workers
A companion guide in the same series.
ACA Employer Mandate and Misclassified Workers
A companion guide in the same series.
Staffing Agency and Leased Worker Benefit Obligations
A companion guide in the same series.
An independent employee benefits consulting firm. We look at the entire benefits program — cost, plan performance, risk and administration.
Switch to CFH. Unhappy with your broker? Your employees won’t notice. You will. →