Group life and AD&D plan design: how much to carry, what is taxable and what to ask a carrier.
Benefit amounts, guaranteed issue, age reductions, imputed income, portability and conversion, explained without reference to any one carrier. Written for the owner or HR lead.
Group Life Is the Most Widely Valued Low-Cost Benefit
It pays a tax-free death benefit to a named beneficiary, at group rates, usually with no medical questions up to a limit.
Basic Life
Employer-paid coverage for every eligible employee, usually a flat amount or a multiple of salary. It is a floor of protection, not a financial plan. Many employers add it first because it reaches every eligible employee. Decide whether the amount fits your workforce, and make sure employees know it exists, since many forget they have it. You can test your own figures with our group life insurance premium calculator.
Supplemental Life
Employee-paid coverage that lets people add to the basic amount, often with spouse and child coverage. It is the main way employees get meaningful protection through work. Employees should compare the cost per amount of coverage with other options before enrolling. Show the rate by age band in enrollment materials so employees can see how the cost changes over time. Try our free life insurance needs calculator to run the numbers for your own group.
AD&D
Accidental death and dismemberment pays an additional amount when death or loss of a limb results from an accident. It is cheap, narrow and widely misunderstood. It pays only for qualifying accidental losses and not for deaths from illness, so it is not a substitute for life insurance. Explain the difference in the guide and review the exclusions with the carrier. Our free supplemental life insurance cost calculator turns this into dollars for your plan.
Flat Amount or Multiple of Salary
The choice affects cost and fairness.
Flat Amount
The same benefit for everyone. Simple to administer and to explain, and it gives lower-paid employees relatively more protection. It can feel generous for some employees and thin for others. Review whether the amount would meaningfully help a family of your typical employee, and consider offering supplemental coverage to fill the gap.
Multiple of Salary
One or two times annual pay is common. It scales with income, which matches the cost of lost earnings, and it raises cost for higher earners. Check how the plan defines salary, including whether bonus or commission is counted. That definition changes the amount paid and should match what payroll actually reports.
A Maximum
Plans cap the benefit at a set amount no matter how high the multiple would go. The cap should be set deliberately. Ask what happens to an employee whose multiple would exceed the cap, and whether the cap applies to supplemental coverage as well. Higher earners are the ones who notice the limit first.
Class-Based Amounts
Different classes of employees can have different amounts if the classes are based on a legitimate business reason and written into the plan. Have counsel or your adviser review the classes before you adopt them. Written definitions, such as full-time, part-time or executive, should be applied consistently so that the plan stays defensible.
Guaranteed Issue and Evidence of Insurability
Group life lets people buy coverage up to a point without medical questions.
Guaranteed Issue
Coverage up to a stated amount is available without answering health questions, if the employee enrolls when first eligible. It is the main reason to buy through work. Employees who see this benefit as optional often skip it and regret it later. Tell them in plain terms that the first eligibility window is the easiest time to get coverage without health questions.
Evidence of Insurability
Amounts above guaranteed issue, and late enrollment, usually require health questions. The carrier may approve, decline or modify the request. Tell employees early which amounts need health questions and how long the carrier takes to decide. They should not assume coverage is in force until the carrier confirms it in writing.
Late Entrants
An employee who waits for a later enrollment may face evidence-of-insurability requirements on amounts they could have had automatically. Make the deadlines clear in enrollment materials and send reminders before the window closes. A missed deadline is one of the most common reasons an employee ends up with less coverage than expected.
Provisions That Change the Value
Four clauses decide what a policy is worth to the employee.
Age Reductions
Benefits often reduce at stated ages, such as sixty-five and seventy. Employers with older workforces should read the schedule closely. Ask the carrier to show the schedule in a one-page example, and compare it across quotes. The rate you see usually reflects the age mix of your group, so changes in workforce age can matter at renewal.
Waiver of Premium
If an employee becomes totally disabled, the carrier can continue coverage without premium. The conditions for the waiver are the conditions that count. Ask how long the employee must be disabled before the waiver starts, how the carrier defines disability, and what proof is needed. Employees need a clear contact in HR to start the process.
Accelerated Death Benefit
Allows part of the benefit to be paid early to a terminally ill employee, subject to the policy’s terms. It reduces the final payout. Because it lowers what beneficiaries receive later, employees should talk to a financial or tax adviser before choosing it. Ask the carrier what documentation it requires and whether it affects other benefits.
Portability and Conversion
When employment ends, an employee may be able to continue coverage by port or convert to an individual policy. Windows are short, and the rates can be much higher. Tell departing employees about their options in exit paperwork, since the deadline to apply is short. Ask the carrier how it handles notice and who sends the forms, so no one misses the window.
Imputed Income Over Fifty Thousand Dollars
A rule that surprises employers every year.
The Threshold
Employer-paid group term life coverage above fifty thousand dollars creates taxable income for the employee, measured using an IRS table of cost by age. Payroll should be set up to calculate the amount each pay period, and your tax adviser can confirm how it applies to your plan. Check whether the employer coverage is combined with any supplemental coverage the employer pays for.
What It Looks Like
The imputed amount appears on payroll and is subject to Social Security and Medicare tax. It is usually small, but it is a payroll task that cannot be skipped. Employees may notice a small line item on their pay stub and ask about it. A short note in the benefits guide explains why it appears and avoids unnecessary calls to HR or payroll.
Employee-Paid Coverage
Coverage the employee pays for with after-tax dollars does not create imputed income. Pre-tax payment through a cafeteria plan can change that. Because the tax treatment depends on how premiums are paid and how the plan is structured, ask your payroll provider or tax adviser to confirm the setup. Do not assume that coverage purchased through a cafeteria plan is treated the same way.
Beneficiaries, Claims and Housekeeping
The benefit only pays where the paperwork is right.
Beneficiary Designations
Employees forget to update them after marriage, divorce or a death. An annual prompt costs nothing and prevents expensive disputes. Build the reminder into open enrollment and the new hire packet, and keep forms easy to find. Missing or outdated designations can delay payment to the family when they most need the benefit.
Claims Process
A claim requires a death certificate and carrier forms. HR staff should know who to call and how to start the claim. Keep a one-page checklist with the carrier’s claims contact, the forms needed and who in HR is responsible. Families in grief should not have to wait while the employer searches for instructions.
Termination and Leaves
Coverage during leave of absence and at termination follows the policy. Spell it out in the leave policy and exit paperwork. Ask the carrier how long coverage continues during unpaid leave and whether premiums must still be collected. Train managers to send leave and termination cases to HR so deadlines are not missed.
What Makes Two Quotes Comparable
Premium is the visible difference. Provisions are the real one.
Rate Guarantee
Group life rates are often guaranteed for a period. A longer guarantee has real value in a rising-rate market. Ask what events can end the guarantee early, such as a major change in headcount, and what the carrier says about the next renewal. A guarantee helps budgeting only if the conditions are clear.
Guaranteed Issue Limits
A higher guaranteed issue amount lowers underwriting friction and is worth asking about. Compare the limit across carriers and ask what happens to employees who elect amounts above it. A higher limit means fewer employees need to answer health questions and fewer enrollments stall.
Participation Requirements
Voluntary coverage may require a minimum enrollment. A quote that assumes high participation can reprice upward if actual enrollment falls short. Ask the carrier what happens if participation drops after the first year, how often the requirement is tested and whether rates can change. Build those answers into your communications and your enrollment goals.
Service Quality
Claims responsiveness, enrollment support and billing accuracy matter more than a small premium gap. Ask each carrier for references and for specifics on claim turnaround, billing support and enrollment help. Employees notice a slow or confusing claim far more than a small difference in cost.
The questions that come before choosing a life plan.
Six questions employers bring us about group life and AD&D.
How much basic life should we provide?
A common design is a flat amount or one times salary. Set it against budget and the role you want the benefit to play, then offer voluntary coverage for the rest.
Is group life taxable to employees?
The death benefit is generally tax-free to the beneficiary. Employer-paid coverage above fifty thousand dollars creates taxable income for the employee while they are alive.
What does AD&D cover that life does not?
It pays only when death or dismemberment results from a covered accident. It is additional coverage, not a replacement for life.
Can employees take their life insurance with them?
Often, through portability or conversion, within a short window after employment ends. The rates and terms are different from group rates.
Do we need evidence of insurability?
Only for amounts above guaranteed issue or for late enrollment. It protects the carrier from adverse selection.
Can we offer different amounts to different groups?
Yes, if the classes are reasonable and written into the plan. Avoid classifications that favor owners without a business reason.
Ready? Send us your renewal, or talk it through with someone first. No cost, no obligation.
General information about group life and AD&D plan design, not legal or tax advice. Tax treatment and plan-specific questions belong with your tax advisor and benefits counsel, and we will bring them in.
Is this legal advice?
No. This page is general information, not legal advice. Rules change and facts differ, so confirm your situation with your attorney or tax advisor.
Related guides.
Group Vision Plan Design
Allowances, frequency and what the premium buys.
Group Life Insurance
Group life for Bloomfield Hills employers.
Supplemental Life and Disability
Voluntary life and disability options.
Core Ancillary Benefits
Dental, vision, life and disability together.
Group-Term Life Imputed Income Under Section 79
How the $50,000 exclusion, IRS Table 2-2 rates, and W-2 code C reporting work.
Send us your renewal.
We’ll tell you whether it looks competitive, where we see opportunity, and the five questions we’d put to your carrier. No cost, and no obligation to move anything.
The renewal letter
Your current plan summary
Contribution split by tier
Enrolled counts by tier
Four documents — two more if your group is 50 or more. Nothing else; every extra one is a reason to postpone.
Laws and rules referenced
26 U.S.C. § 125 — Cafeteria plans: pre-tax premium payments, plan limits and nondiscrimination rules.
This page is general information, not legal or tax advice. Rules change and facts matter, so confirm your situation with counsel or a qualified advisor.
An independent employee benefits consulting firm. We look at the entire benefits program — cost, plan performance, risk and administration.
Switch to CFH. Unhappy with your broker? Your employees won’t notice. You will. →
Cookies on This Site
We use cookies to keep the site working properly and to understand how it is used. You can decline anything that is not essential. See our Privacy Policy for the detail.
- Essential — needed for the site to load and for you to move around it. These cannot be switched off.
- Analytics — tell us which pages get read, so we know what is worth writing more of.
- Advertising — set by third parties such as ad and social platforms to measure and target campaigns.