A school district’s benefits decision is made at the bargaining table, not at renewal.
For Michigan districts the questions come back every year: what MESSA costs against the market, how much Public Act 152 lets the district pay, and what the contract with each employee group allows. We start with the limit and work out from there.
The MESSA question deserves a real comparison, not a default.
MESSA is a nonprofit health insurance provider, a voluntary employees’ beneficiary association, and many districts have used it for years. Whether it fits is a question about rates, coverage, the support the district gets and how renewals move, compared on the same terms as the rest of the market.
Compare on the Same Basis
We price MESSA and carrier options on the same enrollment and the same contribution assumptions, so the comparison shows the difference in cost and not the difference in how the quotes were built. Ask each option to be priced for the same employee groups and the same enrollment so the differences are clear.
Count the Support
Each MESSA group is assigned a field representative, with employer training and support for managing the benefit. That is part of what a district is weighing, and it belongs in the comparison next to price. Ask what training and day-to-day support you would receive from each option.
Know Who Is Eligible
MESSA started as public-school-only and is now open to public employees more broadly. Eligibility for a specific group still depends on the employer and how its plans are bargained, so confirm it for your own staff before planning around it.
The election sets the budget, and each employee group feels it differently.
A district elects each year between the hard cap, the 80% option and an exemption. The election decides how much of the premium the district carries, and the employees see it as their share.
Support Staff
Support staff are often where the budget pressure shows first, because their pay makes the employee share of premium feel heaviest. A comparison that only shows the district’s cost misses the group most likely to push back. Ask how each option would change the employee share by class, and look at it alongside current pay and plan choices.
Administrators and Higher-Ed Staff
K-12 administrators, and higher-education faculty and staff in the same arrangements, often have their own bargaining history. It has to be accounted for rather than averaged away. Gather prior agreements and ask counsel to confirm what must be honored before you compare options.
The Board
The board votes on the election each year. We bring it figures for the hard cap and the 80% option against your actual enrollment, so the vote is taken on numbers. Run the calculator.
Retirees stay on the district’s books for years.
Retiree coverage is a commitment that outlasts the contract that created it. How it is funded decides whether it stays manageable.
Retiree HRAs
Many districts and other public employers use a health reimbursement arrangement to fund retiree coverage with a defined amount. How retiree HRAs work for public employers.
Group Retiree Medical
Where a district keeps a group plan for retirees, plan design, funding and the accounting have to be decided together. Group retiree medical.
Retirees 65 and Older
For retirees on Medicare we can place a group plan built for that population and price it alongside the alternatives. Medicare and retiree benefits.
Start months before the vote.
Quotes may need board approval and union input before anything can change, so the comparison starts earlier than a private renewal would.
Settle the Election
We start with the Public Act 152 election, because it sets the number before any comparison begins. Get that order backwards and the comparison is meaningless. Ask your counsel to confirm which election applies and how it is documented, because later steps depend on it.
Run the Comparison Inside It
We compare MESSA and the rest of the market inside the budget the election allows, on one set of assumptions, and show where each option lands for each employee group. Keep a record of the assumptions so the board and bargaining team can review how each figure was built.
Bring the Board Figures
The board and the bargaining team get the same figures, laid out so that each can see its own question answered. No carrier owns us, so the answer follows the numbers. Prepare answers in advance to the questions each side is likely to ask, with sources noted.
The same approach applies to cities, townships and counties. See public sector employee benefits.
What school districts ask us.
Is MESSA only for school districts?
No. It started as public-school-only and is now open to public employees more broadly, which puts it in front of cities, townships and other public employers as well.
Do you work against MESSA?
No. We are independent and no carrier owns us. We compare MESSA with the rest of the market and show the district which option fits inside its budget.
How early should we start?
Months before the board vote or the bargaining deadline. Quotes may need board approval and union input before anything can change.
Does the review cost anything?
No. We tell you whether the renewal looks competitive, where we see opportunity and the questions we would put to your carrier, with no obligation to move anything.
Related guides.
Schools, Child Care and Education Employers
School-year contracts, part-time aides and summer coverage.
Send us your renewal.
We’ll tell you whether it looks competitive, where we see opportunity, and the five questions we’d put to your carrier. No cost, and no obligation to move anything.
The renewal letter
Your current plan summary
Contribution split by tier
Enrolled counts by tier
Four documents — two more if your group is 50 or more. Nothing else; every extra one is a reason to postpone.
An independent employee benefits consulting firm. We look at the entire benefits program — cost, plan performance, risk and administration.
Switch to CFH. Unhappy with your broker? Your employees won’t notice. You will. →
Cookies on This Site
We use cookies to keep the site working properly and to understand how it is used. You can decline anything that is not essential. See our Privacy Policy for the detail.
- Essential — needed for the site to load and for you to move around it. These cannot be switched off.
- Analytics — tell us which pages get read, so we know what is worth writing more of.
- Advertising — set by third parties such as ad and social platforms to measure and target campaigns.