When Michigan employers search for a benefits partner, they are usually looking for one thing: health and benefits consulting that actually understands their workforce, their budget, and their compliance obligations. Health and benefits consulting brings together group health insurance strategy, cost management, and regulatory guidance under one roof, so HR teams are not left piecing together advice from a carrier call center, a payroll vendor, and a compliance attorney separately.
The short answer: health and benefits consulting is year-round advisory work on an employer’s health plan and the benefits around it. It covers how the plan is funded, how it is designed and priced, how the renewal is negotiated, how it stays compliant with the ACA and ERISA, and how employees get help using it. The consultant’s job is to find the right answer for the employer across carriers and funding arrangements, not to sell one product.
CFH Insurance Consultants provides health and benefits consulting for mid-market employers across Michigan, typically companies with 50 to 500 employees. This guide walks through what health and benefits consulting actually includes, how Michigan carrier options like BCBSM and HAP fit into the picture, and what to look for in a consulting partner.
What Is Health and Benefits Consulting?
Health and benefits consulting is the practice of helping employers design, price, manage, and stay compliant with employee health and benefits programs. It covers group health insurance plan design, carrier and network comparisons, ancillary benefits like dental and vision, cost containment strategies, and the compliance work that comes with offering coverage under the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and ERISA. Unlike a single-carrier sales rep, a health and benefits consulting firm typically works independently of any one insurer, which means its recommendations are based on what fits the employer, not a sales quota.
What a Health and Benefits Consulting Engagement Covers
In practice, health and benefits consulting covers several distinct workstreams throughout the year, not just a once-a-year renewal conversation:
- Funding strategy: fully insured, level-funded, self-funded with stop-loss, or a group health captive, compared on your own claims
- Benefits strategy and plan design tailored to workforce size, industry, and budget
- Carrier and network negotiation across multiple insurers rather than a single quote
- ACA and ERISA compliance guidance, including employer mandate tracking and 1094-C/1095-C reporting support
- ICHRA and QSEHRA implementation for employers exploring defined-contribution alternatives to traditional group plans
- Open enrollment support and employee communication, including calls from employees who want help choosing the plan that fits them
- Pharmacy benefit review, plus voluntary benefits such as accident, critical illness and hospital indemnity, an EAP and a Section 125 plan
- Claims advocacy and ongoing plan performance reviews
A Year of Health and Benefits Consulting, Quarter by Quarter
The engagement runs on the plan year, not just the renewal date. For a plan year that starts January 1, the work falls roughly as below; shift the rows if your plan renews in another month. Our renewal work follows the same five stages on every account, a method we call DATUM.
| Quarter | Consulting Work | Compliance Dates |
|---|---|---|
| January to March | Implement the new plan year: eligibility files to carriers and payroll, ID cards, and the first round of employee claims and billing questions | Forms 1095-C furnished, or a notice posted by March 2 that forms are available on request; CMS creditable coverage disclosure within 60 days of the plan year start |
| April to June | Review early claims, pharmacy trend and large claims; check plan documents, including the Summary Plan Description | Form 5500 preparation for health plans with 100 or more participants at the start of the plan year |
| July to September | Build the renewal strategy: hold the census constant to measure the real increase, model funding options, and take the plan to market | Affordability check for the coming year: 10.22% of pay for 2027 plan years |
| October to December | Negotiate, decide and run open enrollment, including calls from employees choosing a plan | Medicare Part D notice before October 15; gag clause attestation due December 31 |
The third quarter is where most of the money is decided. In July 2026, Michigan’s DIFS posted proposed 2027 small group increases averaging 9.6%, with eight carriers ranging from 7.0% to 14.8% (proposed, not final). A consultant who starts the renewal when the carrier letter arrives is negotiating against that backdrop with no time left to test alternatives.
Emerging Plan Structures: Self-Funded, Level-Funded, and Captive Options
How the plan is funded is one decision inside the engagement, and it is worth revisiting at every renewal. We place fully insured, level-funded, self-funded with stop-loss and group health captive arrangements, so the comparison can be made on your claims rather than on which product a firm happens to sell. Staying fully insured is often the right answer for a smaller or less predictable group.
Self-Funded Plans
Self-funded plans allow employers to assume the financial risk of providing health benefits, paying claims out of their own funds rather than fixed premiums. These plans often reduce insurer profit margins and premium taxes and provide transparency into claims data, enabling targeted cost management.
Pros: Potential cost savings, greater plan design flexibility, access to claims data, and avoidance of state premium taxes.
Cons: Increased risk exposure, need for stop-loss insurance, and more administrative complexity.
Level-Funded Plans
Level-funded plans combine features of self-funding and fully insured models. Employers pay a fixed monthly amount that includes estimated claims, administrative fees, and stop-loss coverage. At the end of the plan year, unused claims funds may be refunded.
Pros: Predictable monthly costs with potential for refunds, protection through stop-loss, and access to claims data.
Cons: Potential variability in renewals, expense of stop-loss, and eligibility criteria limitations.
Group Health Captives
A group health captive lets mid-sized employers self-fund while sharing risk with other employers. Each employer pays for its own expected claims, a layer of larger claims is pooled through a captive insurer the members participate in, and stop-loss coverage sits above that layer. It can give a group that is too small to self-fund comfortably on its own more stable stop-loss pricing and access to its own claims data.
Pros: Shared risk, potential cost savings, tailored plan features, and enhanced governance.
Cons: Complexity in formation and management, capital requirements, and necessity of long-term commitment.
Unbundled Pharmacy Benefit Management (PBM) Carve-Outs
Pharmacy benefit management represents a significant portion of health plan spend. Many employers are exploring unbundled or carve-out PBM arrangements to gain transparency and improve cost control.
Traditional PBMs often bundle administrative fees, rebates, and drug pricing, which can obscure true costs. Unbundled PBMs separate these components, allowing employers and consultants to negotiate more favorable terms and tailor pharmacy programs to workforce needs.
Carving pharmacy out is not right for every group, and the contract terms matter more than the structure. Before any change, have the current arrangement reviewed through pharmacy benefit consulting, then evaluate:
- Transparency of pricing and rebates
- Flexibility in formulary and drug utilization management
- Impact on total cost of care, including medical pharmacy integration
- Administrative and reporting capabilities
Fiduciary Compliance: ERISA, ACA and the CAA
Employers sponsoring group health plans carry fiduciary responsibilities under ERISA, which requires acting prudently and in plan participants’ best interests. With evolving regulatory frameworks including the ACA and the Consolidated Appropriations Act (CAA), compliance complexity has increased, encompassing:
- Plan administration and governance requirements
- Notice delivery and documentation
- Claims handling and appeals
- Employer shared responsibility and affordability testing under ACA
- Transparency in fees and services under CAA provisions
Health and benefits consultants play a critical advisory role, assisting employers with meeting these fiduciary duties through plan design, vendor selection, monitoring, and compliance audits.
Comparing Michigan Carrier Options: BCBSM, HAP, and Beyond
Michigan employers generally have several major carrier options to weigh, and two of the most prominent are Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (BCBSM) and HAP (Health Alliance Plan). BCBSM’s statewide PPO network tends to appeal to employers with staff spread across multiple Michigan regions, and its HMO is Blue Care Network. HAP, based in Detroit and affiliated with Henry Ford Health, is often weighed for its HMO options in Southeast Michigan specifically.
Neither carrier is automatically the right fit for every employer — the better network, plan structure, and pricing depend on where employees live, what providers they already use, and how the employer wants to balance premium cost against out-of-pocket exposure. This is exactly where independent health and benefits consulting adds value: rather than starting from a single carrier’s product line, a consultant can compare BCBSM, HAP, Priority Health, and other Michigan group health insurance providers side by side against the same criteria, and negotiate on the employer’s behalf.
One detail changes many of these decisions. Doctors often take both a carrier’s HMO and its PPO, so many employees want a PPO rather than need one. Checking where your employees actually get care before choosing a plan type is basic consulting work, and our comparison of HMO vs PPO vs EPO plans walks through the trade-offs.
Health and Benefits Consulting and ACA Compliance
Compliance is not a side service in health and benefits consulting; it is part of the core work. Applicable large employers, those with 50 or more full-time employees including full-time equivalents, are subject to the employer mandate and report coverage on Forms 1094-C and 1095-C under Internal Revenue Code Sections 6055 and 6056. Affordability is 9.96% of pay for 2026 plan years and 10.22% for 2027, measured on the lowest-cost self-only option that meets minimum value using a safe harbor such as W-2 wages, rate of pay or the federal poverty line.
For 2027 the penalties are $3,780 per full-time employee after the first 30 for not offering coverage to at least 95% of full-time employees, and $5,670 for each full-time employee who receives a marketplace subsidy when coverage is unaffordable or lacks minimum value. We can help you with the filing, and our page on ACA reporting explains what the year of records behind it looks like.
Choosing a Health and Benefits Consulting Firm
This page covers what the work is. Choosing who does it is a separate decision with its own criteria, and our guide to choosing a benefits consulting firm includes a scorecard you can run on your current firm. Two questions matter most for the engagement described here: how will it be staffed through the year, and how is the firm paid on your account, in writing?
Our answer to the first: for proper coverage of an account we work in teams of five, an account executive, an account manager, a plan analyst, customer service and IT. Clients also get access to CPAs and ERISA attorneys through the firm, and employees can reach us through 24/7 chat.
Frequently Asked Questions About Health and Benefits Consulting
What is health and benefits consulting?
Health and benefits consulting is professional guidance that helps employers design, price, and manage employee health plans and broader benefits packages, while staying compliant with ACA and ERISA requirements. It typically includes carrier comparisons, plan design, and ongoing plan administration support.
Do independent consultants work with carriers like BCBSM and HAP?
Yes. Independent health and benefits consultants generally hold appointments with multiple licensed Michigan carriers, which allows them to compare options such as BCBSM and HAP against each other and against other statewide and regional carriers, rather than being limited to a single insurer’s plans.
What size businesses benefit most from health and benefits consulting?
Health and benefits consulting tends to deliver the most value for mid-market employers, generally those with 50 to 500 employees, where benefits decisions carry real financial weight and ACA employer mandate obligations are fully in effect, but the company may not have a dedicated in-house benefits team.
How is a health and benefits consultant paid?
Most independent health and benefits consultants are compensated through standard commissions paid by the carrier the employer ultimately selects, similar to how a real estate agent is paid by a seller. Employers should ask any prospective consultant to explain their compensation structure directly.
Ready to talk through your options? Contact CFH Insurance Consultants at 248.370.8853 or book a free consultation to discuss health and benefits consulting for your Michigan business.
What does an employee health plan consultant do?
An employee health plan consultant works on the employer’s health plan through the year: comparing carriers and funding arrangements, designing and pricing the plan, negotiating the renewal, reviewing claims and pharmacy costs, keeping the plan compliant with the ACA and ERISA, and helping employees use their coverage. The renewal is one part of the job. Much of the value comes from work done in the months before the carrier’s letter arrives.
Is health and benefits consulting only for large employers?
No. In Michigan a small group plan can start on the first of any month with as few as one W-2 employee, and the employer is not required to contribute. Smaller employers still face plan design, carrier and compliance decisions, and options such as a QSEHRA or ICHRA. The work scales with the group: a small employer has fewer compliance filings, but the carrier and plan choices matter just as much.
Unhappy with your current broker? Switch to CFH. Your employees won’t notice. You will.
