A bonus nobody can predict does not change behavior. It only changes the payroll.
Incentive plans are meant to direct effort and keep people. Many do neither, because the measures are unclear, the payout feels arbitrary or it arrives too late to matter. We structure bonus and incentive plans that people understand, that support retention, and that are designed alongside your benefits investment.
Every incentive plan is built from a few decisions, and each one changes the result.
We work through the choices in order, because a plan with a clear purpose and a muddled measure will still fail.
What You Are Paying For
Company results, team goals and individual performance drive different behavior. We match the measure to the behavior you want, so the plan rewards what you actually need. Choosing the right measure is the first step in incentive plan design. Measures drive behavior.
Line of Sight
Employees need to see how their work moves the measure. A plan tied only to company profit feels like a lottery to most staff, which is why we often blend measures by level. Blended measures give employees line of sight.
Threshold, Target, Maximum
A payout curve decides when the plan starts paying and how much upside exists. We model it against realistic outcomes, so the cost in a good year is a number you have already seen. Modeling the payout curve keeps incentive costs predictable.
Timing and Vesting
Paying at year-end rewards the year; deferring part rewards staying. We help you decide how much of the plan should do each, because retention is a timing question. Timing and vesting shape both reward and retention in an incentive plan, so they are decided on purpose.
Incentive pay has consequences beyond the bonus check.
How a plan is written affects overtime, taxes and what you have promised. We flag the rules at design time, and counsel or a CPA available through our firm confirms where a conclusion is needed.
Overtime and the Regular Rate
Nondiscretionary bonuses paid to non-exempt employees generally must be included when calculating overtime. We design for it so the plan does not create an unpaid overtime problem. Including bonuses in the regular rate keeps incentive plans compliant with overtime rules for non-exempt staff.
Deferred Payouts
Deferring incentive pay can trigger complex tax timing rules. We structure the design and bring in a CPA or attorney to confirm the treatment before the plan is finalized. Professional review keeps deferred incentive pay compliant. A CPA or attorney confirms the tax timing.
Written Terms
Unclear eligibility or forfeiture terms become disputes when someone leaves before payout. We make sure the plan document says exactly what happens. Clear written terms prevent incentive plan disputes when an employee leaves before the payout date. Spell out forfeiture terms.
Incentives and benefits compete for the same budget and the same attention.
We model incentives next to benefits spending, so you can see the full cost of retention and decide where each dollar works hardest.
One Budget View
A richer health plan and a larger bonus pool are both retention tools. We show their costs side by side, so the trade-off is explicit. A single budget view makes the trade-off between incentives and benefits clear before either is increased.
Different Employees, Different Levers
Some employees value predictable benefits; others value upside. We help you balance both, because one plan rarely fits everyone. Balancing predictable benefits and incentive upside helps a total rewards program appeal to a wider range of employees. One plan rarely fits all.
Making It Visible
An incentive nobody understands earns no loyalty. We help communicate the plan and show it in total rewards statements, so employees see its value. Clear communication makes incentive pay a retention tool, and total rewards statements keep its value visible all year.
What employers ask about incentive plans.
Should every employee be eligible?
Not necessarily. Broad eligibility builds shared purpose; targeted plans focus on roles with clear influence. We help you decide based on what you want the plan to do. Eligibility should follow the incentive plan’s purpose. Broad and targeted plans do different jobs.
Is discretionary better than formula-based?
Discretion gives flexibility, but employees cannot aim at it. Formula plans direct effort but need careful design. Many plans combine the two. Blending formula and discretion keeps incentive plans flexible and fair, with the formula doing most of the work.
How do we avoid paying out in a bad year?
Build a funding threshold into the plan, so payouts depend on the organization reaching a level of results first. We model that trigger before it goes in writing. A funding threshold protects the business in weak years. Model the trigger first.
Send us your renewal.
We’ll tell you whether it looks competitive, where we see opportunity, and the five questions we’d put to your carrier. No cost, and no obligation to move anything.
The renewal letter
Your current plan summary
Contribution split by tier
Enrolled counts by tier
Four documents — two more if your group is 50 or more. Nothing else; every extra one is a reason to postpone.
An independent employee benefits consulting firm. We look at the entire benefits program — cost, plan performance, risk and administration.
Switch to CFH. Unhappy with your broker? Your employees won’t notice. You will. →