Small enough to be handled quickly. That’s the problem.
Under 50 employees, benefits usually land on someone who already has another job. The office manager, the controller, the owner.
The renewal arrives in a PDF, the increase is what it is, and nobody walks you through what drove it or what the alternatives were. That is not so much a service failure by your broker as a business model — small groups are priced to be handled quickly. We handle them the same way we handle a 400-life employer: with a dedicated team of five, backed by the full firm behind them.
Small does not mean exempt.
The compliance line moves at 50 employees. The cost structure moves on a different schedule entirely. Here is where a 2-to-50 employer actually stands, dimension by dimension.
Regulatory Position
See the full compliance calendar and what applies at your size →
You are in ACA small-group rating in most states, so your own claims history does not set next year’s premium. The employer mandate — and the 1094-C/1095-C reporting that comes with it — does not apply until 50 full-time equivalents. COBRA already applies once you cross 20 employees, and ERISA disclosure rules apply regardless of size.
We track how close you are to 50 full-time equivalents, not just whether you have crossed it, and flag the compliance shift — COBRA, then ALE reporting — before it turns up as a surprise in a filing.
Funding & Cost Structure
Nearly every group this size is fully insured and community-rated. Self-funding is rare below 50 lives because per-person claims volatility is too high for a small group to absorb, and stop-loss carriers price it accordingly. Level-funded plans, which return a share of unused claims budget, start to make sense as a group approaches the top of this range.
We model the level-funded alternative against your renewal every year once you are within range of it, instead of waiting for a bad renewal to force the conversation.
Administrative Load
Most employers this size have no dedicated benefits staff. The person running benefits is doing it alongside payroll, hiring and everything else, and carrier service at this size is built around a call center, not a named contact.
For proper coverage of an account, you get a dedicated team of five, not a queue. The same people handle enrollment, billing and claims escalation, so you are not re-explaining your group every time you call.
Talent & Retention
Benefits at this size compete for the same candidates as much larger employers, without the budget to match their headline plan design. Ancillary benefits — dental, vision, life, disability — often move a candidate’s decision more than the exact medical deductible does.
We help you decide where a marginal dollar of budget buys the most perceived value, rather than spreading a small increase evenly across every line.
Your rates were approved by the state before your renewal arrived.
At your size the trend is not a forecast anyone has to guess at. It is a filed, public document.
The number is already published
Michigan requires small-group rates to be filed with the state and approved before the plan year starts, then publishes every carrier’s change with the covered lives behind it — a statewide average approved at 11.1 percent for 2026 and proposed at 9.6 percent for 2027. The part that matters for your renewal: your carrier is not holding a better number back. It does not have one to give.
So the spread between carriers is the whole opportunity
The 2027 filings run from about 7 percent at one end to nearly 15 at the other. For a group your size that eight-point spread is not market color — it is the menu. Spending the renewal window negotiating with the incumbent spends it on the one thing that cannot move. The lever is a carrier whose filing is lower, quoted on the same plan design so the comparison still means something.
Two refinements before anyone quotes a statewide figure at you. The published average blends HMO and insurer carriers, and for 2027 those two filed materially different numbers — so which figure describes your market depends on which kind of plan you have. And Michigan requires per-member rating with no family tier, so your own renewal moves with your own census on top of the filed change. At your size, one hire or one departure swings your average age further than it would anywhere else.
At your size the renewal is the book — and that is the useful part.
A renewal is your own claims experience blended with the carrier’s book rate, and what sets the mix is enrolled contracts, not employees. Full credibility is commonly reached at a thousand. Below fifty contracts a carrier will not even release claims information — so your own experience is carrying almost none of the weight.
| Enrolled contracts | Your own claims | The book rate | What that means |
|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | 2.5% | 97.5% | Your claims year is almost invisible in the rate. |
| 50 | 5% | 95% | About where carriers start releasing claims information at all. |
| 100 | 10% | 90% | Nine tenths of the increase describes the market, not you. |
| 250 | 25% | 75% | Still mostly the book — but one large claimant now shows. |
| 500 | 50% | 50% | The market figure and your own experience carry equal weight. |
| 750 | 75% | 25% | Mostly your own claims. The market number is context now. |
| 1,000+ | 100% | — | The renewal is your own claims experience, priced. |
An employer with two to fifty employees sits at the top of this table, on or above the shaded row. That is not a limitation to apologize for. It is the single most useful fact about your renewal, because it tells you exactly where to look and where not to bother.
Your increase is not a verdict on your people.
A hard claims year cannot show up in a rate that is nineteen twentieths book. Whatever the renewal letter says, it is describing the carrier’s block and a filing the state approved months earlier — not the health of your staff. Anyone implying otherwise is guessing, and the arithmetic says they are wrong.
So the lever is which book you are in.
If your own experience carries no weight, the only things that can move your number are the carrier you sit with, the plan design you are on, and whether anyone tested the alternatives before the renewal date. All three are decisions, and all three are made long before the letter arrives.
You are already paying a broker. Find out what you have been getting for it.
The commission is built into your premium whether or not anyone earns it. On a filed rate nobody can change the price — so at your size the only live question is who receives that money and what they do for it. It costs nothing to ask, and your current broker has every reason not to raise it.
Speed, with a number on it.
Ask what the standard is for an enrollment, a termination, an ID card, a billing dispute — and what the elapsed time has actually been. Every one of those arrives and leaves as dated correspondence, so the clock is already running whether anyone reads it or not.
Accuracy, with a deadline on it.
Ask how many billing discrepancies were found and recovered rather than quietly paid. This is not a soft question. Some carriers will not adjust a billing error past 120 days, so one caught late is not an error any more — it is a loss.
And who, by name.
Ask who is assigned to your account, who answers when that person is out, and which administration the firm performs rather than advises on. For proper coverage of an account we work in service teams of five.
None of those questions is about us. They are the questions a small employer can put to whoever is already being paid, and the answers are checkable either way. If they come back thin, the switch is straightforward and it starts the same way everything here starts — with four documents and a reading of what they actually say.
What employers your size ask us.
We only have 14 people. Is that too small for a benefits consultant?
No. Group size decides which plans you can buy; it does not decide how well you are advised. Our smallest clients get the same five-person team as our largest.
Do we have to offer coverage at all?
Not below 50 full-time equivalents. Most employers this size offer it to hire and keep people, not because they are required to.
What does it cost to work with you?
In most cases nothing beyond the broker commission already built into your premium. We will tell you exactly how we are paid before you decide anything.
Your industry changes how the plan is run, not what it costs.
Below fifty employees you are community rated, so the rate is not about your claims and not about your industry. What industry does change at this size is who is eligible, how fast the workforce turns over, and how much administration the enrollment actually takes.
Other Services
Salons, repair shops and membership organizations, where a handful of family enrollments move the whole tier mix and one owner decision changes the contribution strategy.
Retail Trade
Part-time and variable hours mean the eligibility definition, not the plan design, decides who is actually covered — and it has to be written down before somebody asks.
Accommodation and Food Services
High turnover makes waiting periods, enrollment paperwork and continuation notices the real workload, month after month.
Construction
Seasonal crews and rehires make eligibility and continuation the recurring question, and a plan built for a steady headcount handles it badly.
Every sector we serve
- Accommodation and Food Services
- Administrative and Support and Waste Management
- Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting
- Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation
- Construction
- Educational Services
- Finance and Insurance
- Health Care and Social Assistance
- Information
- Management of Companies and Enterprises
- Manufacturing
- Mining, Quarrying, and Oil and Gas Extraction
- Mortgage lending
- Other Services
- Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services
- Public Administration
- Real Estate and Rental and Leasing
- Retail Trade
- Transportation and Warehousing
- Utilities
- Wholesale Trade
Send us your renewal.
We’ll tell you whether it looks competitive, where we see opportunity, and what questions we’d be asking your carrier. No cost, and no obligation to move anything.
An independent employee benefits consulting firm. We look at the entire benefits program — cost, plan performance, risk and administration.
Bloomfield Hills, MI 48304
248.370.8853
Colorado Springs, CO 80921
719.425.2649
Houston, TX 77084
281.404.5670
Cookies on this site
We use cookies to keep the site working properly and to understand how it is used. You can decline anything that is not essential. See our Privacy Policy for the detail.
- Essential — needed for the site to load and for you to move around it. These cannot be switched off.
- Analytics — tell us which pages get read, so we know what is worth writing more of.
- Advertising — set by third parties such as ad and social platforms to measure and target campaigns.